Aircoookie
Issue when trying to add more then 10 digital buses
What happened?
The 10 buses limit is not clear , It was increased recently as I see in const.h but if you try to add more then 10 and you reboot then it will go back to 10 buses only .
The behavior before was that you can not add more then 10 digital buses as after 10 the led output will be grayed same as below
To Reproduce Bug
Add more then 10 digital buses
Expected Behavior
Exceeding the limit for digital buses should not be allowed in UI
Install Method
Self-Compiled
What version of WLED?
WLED 0.15.0-b7 (build 2410270)
Which microcontroller/board are you seeing the problem on?
ESP32
Relevant log/trace output
No response
Anything else?
No response
Code of Conduct
- [X] I agree to follow this project's Code of Conduct
🤔 as this (more than 10 busses on esp32) is a new feature, I think its an option to use as-is for 0.15.RC1, and fix it later.
We should then add a warning to the release notes, saying that >10 outputs are available technically, however the LED settings page has known problems with it, and it may not be possible to configure more outputs than in older versions.
Or we are lucky and someone finds a fix.
You could change the label as "needs investigation" and remove bug as I could not do that .
One thing more noticed is that this limit issue is also there when I tried to test with DDP output , in this case if you save the page with more then 10 then settings/leds will bug and all output will be gone ( strange thing is the master still control the slave even if the setting page is empty ) , rebooting does not help and factory reset might the only option as editing cfg.json might be too much effort
Debug build did not show any useful error , still the cfg.json is below when saving with more then 10 DDP output
morethen_10_ddp_output_cfg.json
Just FYI , I do not need 10 outputs with leds nor with DDP . I am happy with 2 and the max I have is 4 output for a unit I made only for testing . But we have received some questions from users with regard to using more then 10 outputs with DDP as they wanted that for a long time so this is not unrealistic setups if you care to check discord .
Hi, I would like to try DDP more than 10 Athom GU10 WLED bulbs, currently I have 18 bulbs split into 2 ESP32 ethernet controllers and another master controller, if I can try everything with just one controller it would be great, I would like to be able to eliminate the delay to have smooth effects like wipe and another effects; will it be possible to add more than 10 DDP from the next version of WLED? I am very interested in adding many GU10 bulbs and I am available for all tests; thank you!!!
@tech1977 ,As the output of more then 10 could be edge case so might be not solved ,for DDP if you need more then 10 output then we have found a simple workaround , in one of the slaves just also use DDP to other slaves , you can see details in discord here https://discord.com/channels/473448917040758787/473448917543944193/1317398474626433024 , if you do that then you can still from one master control the end slaves ( nested DDP ) with segments on the master so that is 32 segments on esp32 .
@dosipod I did this with 18 test bulbs: bulbs from 1-10 on DDP RGBW output of the first ESP32 ethernet bulbs from 11-18 on DDP RGBW output of the second ESP32 ethernet third ESP32 ethernet as master with DDP RGBW output the 2 previous ESP32s for a total of 18 pixels
It would be nice to have this bug fixed for an upcoming QuinLED board that has 15 analog outputs. Is anyone working on this and/or has pointers on how to go about fixing this? It sounds like the issue is with the settings page. I have yet to test actual output, but configuring 11 outputs at compile seems to at least work correctly through debug.
@PaoloTK Sure it is a work in progress , look at those two https://github.com/Aircoookie/WLED/issues/4389 https://github.com/Aircoookie/WLED/issues/4380
Or better get in touch with the guys on QuinLED discord for updates and workarounds . We may close this issue or keep it for DDP related as we do not wish to have so many issues related to the same thing .
@PaoloTK Sure it is a work in progress , look at those two #4389 #4380
I don't think those are affected by the problem reported in this issue? Or is it a more general bug that breaks both certain outputs when used with specific GPIOs due to hardware and all outputs if more than 10 are configured?
Or better get in touch with the guys on QuinLED discord for updates and workarounds . We may close this issue or keep it for DDP related as we do not wish to have so many issues related to the same thing .
Sorry, my message wasn't clear. I wasn't speaking as a customer, but as a dev. I would like to get the bug fixed myself and have started looking into it, but was wondering if anyone had already made some progress to save time.
For example I have noticed this line loops up to i=10:
https://github.com/Aircoookie/WLED/blob/3c19692312df2eda362db394faeae5f92bb5f747/wled00/data/settings_leds.htm#L609
However increasing that alone hasn't fixed the bug, so need to look deeper.
At the moment I do not have the HW to test such number of outputs so we just kept this issue for DDP workarounds , the original case was here https://github.com/Aircoookie/WLED/issues/4301 . I think when the guys are now reporting issues with less then 10 outputs it may make sense to focus on that before saying why more then 10 do not work .
You could also open a PR if you think you have something to add that may fix it but I think you would need to dig a bit deeper for that as what you just listed about the settings page is just a ui thing .
