AdguardTeam
Custom filtering rules ignored with DNS allowlist
Issue description: With the latest version of AdGuard Home (0.104.3) custom filtering rules get ignored, if a matching DNS allowlist entry exists.
Suggested solution: Please add an option to choose if custom filter rules or DNS list entries are prefered. Default behavior should be that custom filtering rules are always prefered.
Example of issue: Blocked google.com only for specific clients, which worked until a DNS allowlist was added which whitelists google.com.
Custom filterung rule: ||google.com^$client='192.168.0.82' DNS allowlist: https://raw.githubusercontent.com/notracking/hosts-blocklists-scripts/master/hostnames.whitelist.txt
Result right now, which should not happen:
Thank you for your report, we'll see what we can do without breaking other people's settings. An option is one option (heh), but perhaps a more flexible model is needed.
I am running into this issue as well as that's actually how I would of expected this to work.
Whitelists are really good and convenient to override blacklists, but in my view custom rules should always trump both (override any backlist and/or whitelist).
yes, also running into this issue. would have thought custom is prefered.
Just ran into this. I subscribe to a generic whitelist for known services (was having trouble with Google services without it). But, that whitelist allows youtube.com, which I want to block. My custom filter to block youtube.com is being ignored because the whitelist I subscribe to contains an allow for it. Custom filters should trump both block/allow lists!
Bumping this issue. I'm not sure why this hasn't been properly addressed yet. Custom Rules should take priority over all other rules. If not this, then maybe add some sort of priority modifier that goes beyond the $important modifier.
