Aoe_Scheduler icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
Aoe_Scheduler copied to clipboard

License/Magento 2

Open piotrekkaminski opened this issue 9 years ago • 29 comments

Hi,

Knowing how popular AOE scheduler is, i was thinking if it would make sense to have it by default include in Magento 2. So i have couple questions:

  • are you guys planning on a Magento 2 version?
  • if not, would you consider license change to MIT or similar so we could include parts of the code in Magento 2?

Thanks for sharing such amazing piece of code with the community!

Piotr

piotrekkaminski avatar Mar 11 '15 00:03 piotrekkaminski

Hi @piotrekkaminski,

I really think Magento's native cron functionality should be a lot closer to what we're doing with Aoe_Scheduler compared to how it is now (both for Magento 1 and Magento 2). This does not only affect the extra interfaces like the timeline view and allowing the edit and create jobs, but also cleaning up the domain model behind the scenes.

I'd love to see Aoe_Scheduler or something similar be part of Magento 2 and while I wasn't planning on migrating the module to Magento 2 in the near future this sounds like a great Hackathon project.

Since I don't feel too passionate about the license I'm sure we'll be able make sure it's compatible with Magento 2.

Question remains if this should stay a separate module (maintained by me/AOE/community) or be part of the Magento core.

Since we started a very similar conversation for Aoe_TemplateHints and Aoe_Profiler in different places I suggest we discuss this in person, for example at the Pre-Imagine Hackathon :) What do you think?

Cheers, Fabrizio

fbrnc avatar Mar 11 '15 03:03 fbrnc

sure - however can you let me know high level what you don't like about the domain model? I'm ok with having aoe_scheduler as a separate thing - but want to make sure Magento supports it well and you don't have to do any crazy stuff inside.

piotrekkaminski avatar Mar 11 '15 20:03 piotrekkaminski

any progress on this guys? would be awesome to see this in Mage2

jonpday avatar Nov 12 '15 01:11 jonpday

@fbrnc any progress on this? Would be happy to participate

redboxmarcins avatar May 26 '16 11:05 redboxmarcins

I'd also love to see Aoe_Scheduler-type functionality be available for M2, either in the core or via a third-party extension.

erikhansen avatar Jun 30 '16 16:06 erikhansen

https://marketplace.magento.com/asulpunto-cronedit.html Can use this for Magento 2

shahankitb997 avatar Jan 06 '17 06:01 shahankitb997

@piotrekkaminski Any progress on this?

brobie avatar Mar 14 '17 15:03 brobie

bump

redboxmarcins avatar Mar 14 '17 16:03 redboxmarcins

Interested in this as well..

erfanimani avatar Mar 14 '17 16:03 erfanimani

Hi @fbrnc

When We can be expected The Aoe_Scheduler for Magento 2??

devamitbera avatar Mar 23 '17 12:03 devamitbera

Would love to see Magento 2 core cron work more like Aoe_Scheduler.

andrewkett avatar Mar 29 '17 03:03 andrewkett

bump +1 ... are you planning to develop a magento 2 solution @fbrnc ? if not, what do you use or plan to use for magento 2?

brandontamm avatar Aug 01 '17 19:08 brandontamm

+1

bodiski avatar Sep 08 '17 14:09 bodiski

+1

ksiamro avatar Sep 14 '17 08:09 ksiamro

Hi all,

We couldn't wait no more, so we did it, https://www.wyomind.com/magento2/cron-scheduler-magento.html I hope this one will be as so good as the AOE scheduler! Cheers! Wyomind.

wyomind avatar Sep 21 '17 16:09 wyomind

@wyomind Awesome! It would be great if you could also publish the extension directly on Github and then allow people to download it via Packagist, similar to how these extensions are setup:

https://github.com/classyllama/ClassyLlama_AvaTax https://github.com/turnto/magento2-turnto-socialcommerce

erikhansen avatar Sep 21 '17 16:09 erikhansen

You guys rock Wyomind! It's been almost a year without this essential extension. I'm guessing AOE kinda left the open source portion of the community and is now focusing on paid project-work (which makes sense.)

So glad the open-source community continues to live on!

brandontamm avatar Sep 21 '17 16:09 brandontamm

Awesome, really good news, thanks @wyomind!

(just informational, since it wasn't mentioned yet in this thread: someone started working on adding this functionality to the core of Magento2, but it has still a long way to go I think: https://github.com/magento/magento2/pull/10721)

hostep avatar Sep 21 '17 19:09 hostep

Nice! Thanks Wyomind

erfanimani avatar Sep 22 '17 00:09 erfanimani

@wyomind - I love you guys. Life savers.

iwebmagento avatar Nov 16 '17 08:11 iwebmagento

@erikhansen oh! by the way, the source code is available on Github https://github.com/wyomind/cronscheduler

wyomind avatar Nov 16 '17 13:11 wyomind

And also we offer a pro version (paid version) with many additional features https://www.wyomind.com/fr/magento2/cron-scheduler-pro-magento.html

wyomind avatar Nov 16 '17 13:11 wyomind

@wyomind could you publish latest version to github? https://github.com/wyomind/cronscheduler/releases - 1.0.1.5 https://www.wyomind.com/magento2/cron-scheduler-magento.html#changelog - 1.2.0

Will be support for magento 2.2.x?

ihor-sviziev avatar Nov 23 '17 14:11 ihor-sviziev

@ihor-sviziev Just did. It is already compatible with Mage 2.2

wyomind avatar Nov 23 '17 14:11 wyomind

@wyomind magento 2.2 supports both php 7.0 and php 7.1, while this module isn't supporting php 7.1. So actually it's not full support of 2.2

ihor-sviziev avatar Nov 23 '17 14:11 ihor-sviziev

@ihor-sviziev sorry. the good composer.json file has been pushed now.

wyomind avatar Nov 23 '17 14:11 wyomind

@wyomind do you have an ability to "Schedule now" cron job? "Run now" in Pro version is not the same because it can be executed via different Linux user with different memory limit settings.

oleksandr-butenko avatar Nov 28 '17 12:11 oleksandr-butenko

@oleksandr-butenko in the free version, there only one button to "generate & run the tasks" (same as bin/magento cron:run)

wyomind avatar Nov 28 '17 13:11 wyomind

I just noticed Magento 2.2.2 now comes with something like this built-in, although it's a very stripped down version. It looks like this is part of that dotmailer module which is now included by default in Magento. You can find it in a very illogical place under Reports => Marketing Automation => Cron Tasks (there is also a handy 'Log Viewer' section added by the dotmailer module)

hostep avatar Jan 24 '18 13:01 hostep