Niagara-Issues icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
Niagara-Issues copied to clipboard

Google Podcasts controls (10s back/30s ahead instead of previous/next track)

Open curio77 opened this issue 5 years ago • 4 comments

Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe. For Google Podcasts, Niagara shows the same controls as for any media player, and they work the same way (switch to previous/next track). However, the Podcasts app's own control panel in the status dropdown (and in-app) has the backwards and forwards controls replaced with 10s rewind and 30s jump-ahead. With podcasts, this makes more sense than the media controls that switch tracks (because you rarely skip podcasts like you skip songs).

Describe the solution you'd like It'd be great if Niagara could adapt the widget display for the Google Podcasts app in the manner of the app's own controls. I cannot judge the feasability of this in terms of whether there's an API for these modified controls. Also, I don't know how other podcasts apps' controls are set up and whether this could apply to them as well or whether a special handling of a particular app (such as Google Podcasts) would be appropriate to begin with.

curio77 avatar Mar 26 '20 13:03 curio77

That's a cool idea @curio77. I'm not sure if that's feasible, but let's try it out! Hope it's understandable that this is a low priority issue though.

8bitPit avatar May 13 '20 20:05 8bitPit

To better plan ahead and give users an estimate of which features will be added to Niagara, I’ve decided to close all feature requests that are unlikely to be implemented this or next year (2021 & 2022). This is one of those, unfortunately. I'm sorry.

8bitPit avatar Mar 21 '21 21:03 8bitPit

It is an issue for all Podcast client apps. I also would very much appreciate this.

This is a real stopper for me to use the media widget – and so to buy the Pro version. It is unusable with podcast as most times users want to skip a certain time forward instead of jumping two hours forward to the next full episode.

tasmo avatar Dec 06 '21 09:12 tasmo

I agree that this feature would be neat indeed. I'll reopen the ticket but keep it at low priority.

8bitPit avatar Dec 21 '21 14:12 8bitPit

Agreed, ran into this today. Frustrating to have to open app to fast forward through commercials present on most podcasts.

Zdmb91 avatar Oct 14 '22 19:10 Zdmb91

With the recent end-of-life announcement for Google Podcasts, this issue no longer seems worth development effort if implemented for that player alone. Otherwise, I would welcome it!

UrsKR avatar Oct 09 '23 05:10 UrsKR

Another Google service bites the dust 🫡 Thank you very much for the update @UrsKR. @Maxr1998 recently checked ou several podcast apps and noticed that most of them (e.g., Spotify) rebinds the next and previous track buttons to x seconds ahead/back actions, so I believe we can leave it as it is. If you have any objections, please let me know.

8bitPit avatar Oct 09 '23 11:10 8bitPit