APIcast icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
APIcast copied to clipboard

resolver.t

Open eguzki opened this issue 2 years ago • 2 comments

eguzki avatar Jun 07 '22 08:06 eguzki

I think in two options here:

  • add some logic inside http.d/init.conf or cli/environment.lua;
  • a second conf/nginx.conf.liquid for tests;

First option can be a problem because it will change some almost static files to a more dynamic one, but this is better than a second file with a lot of duplicated content and another block inside Blackbox.pm

The Problem

  • There is two calls to resty.resolver - one inside environment.lua and another inside init.conf.
  • These two calls related to resty.resolver initialization do not pass the path parameter, ignoring any attempt to configure a custom resolv.conf.

These are the code that APIcast execute:

-- http.d/init.conf
require('resty.resolver').init()
-- cli/environment.lua
local resolver = require('resty.resolver')
resolver.init_nameservers
  • If these functions are called without the path parameter, the machine/container /etc/resolv.conf and the RESOLVER environment variable - if defined - will be added to the list of nameservers.
  • If one of the functions are called with the path parameter, the custom resolv.conf will be added together with /etc/resolv.conf and the RESOLVER environment variable.

Proposal

Remove one of the resty.resolver calls and standardize the name of the variable that points to a custom resolv.conf. Calling both these functions with path parameter will duplicate the nameservers.

Since this needs more modifications than a single file and a environment variable name, I will wait for suggestions.

hector-vido avatar Nov 24 '23 03:11 hector-vido

This pull request https://github.com/3scale/APIcast/pull/1432 is working but since there is a commented line and a "strange" variable name, more discussion is desirable.

hector-vido avatar Nov 26 '23 02:11 hector-vido