vc-data-model icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
vc-data-model copied to clipboard

Published 20 hours ago • verified publisher icon w3c

Add SD-JWT-VC to Ecosystem Compatibility section

Open brentzundel opened this issue 7 months ago • 2 comments

per https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/w3c-archive/2025Apr/0606.html

§5.11 Ecosystem Compatibility should explicitly list SD-JWT and SD-JWT-VC to paragraph 1 which lists digital credential formats that do not natively use the VCDM. SD-JWT-VC even explicitly specifies it does not use the VCDM v1.0, v1.1, or v2.0. As SD-JWT(-VC) is a popular VC format for eIDAS it should be explicitly stated like the others.

brentzundel avatar Apr 22 '25 22:04 brentzundel

The issue was discussed in a meeting on 2025-04-23

  • no resolutions were taken
View the transcript

1.1. VCDM comments.

Brent Zundel: "§5.11 Ecosystem Compatibility should explicitly list SD-JWT and SD-JWT-VC to paragraph 1 which lists digital credential formats that do not natively use the VCDM. SD-JWT-VC even explicitly specifies it does not use the VCDM v1.0, v1.1, or v2.0. As SD-JWT(-VC) is a popular VC format for eIDAS it should be explicitly stated like the others.".

Brent Zundel: comment source.

Brent Zundel: For each of these comments, I will provide text and link to source of comment.

See github issue vc-data-model#1593.

Brent Zundel: comment on VCDM, text suggests say we list SD-JWT-VC to the ecosystem compatibility section. The suggested response will be that we plan to address comment in future version of specification.

Ivan Herman: Any response we make is better to send via email.

Brent Zundel: I will do that.

Kevin Dean: Is there something we can add to the response to provide reasoning? Out of scope for current scope of work?

Brent Zundel: This is an editorial change, we can address it under our current charter, seeing how ideally we shouldn't change text of REC, we can address this later.

Michael Jones: That's fine.

iherman avatar Apr 23 '25 16:04 iherman

This was discussed during the vcwg meeting on 25 April 2025.

View the transcript

VCDM comments

<brent> w3c/vc-data-model#1593

<brent> "§5.11 Ecosystem Compatibility should explicitly list SD-JWT and SD-JWT-VC to paragraph 1 which lists digital credential formats that do not natively use the VCDM. SD-JWT-VC even explicitly specifies it does not use the VCDM v1.0, v1.1, or v2.0. As SD-JWT(-VC) is a popular VC format for eIDAS it should be explicitly stated like the others."

<brent> comment source

brent: For each of these comments, I will provide text and link to source of comment.

brent: comment on VCDM, text suggests say we list SD-JWT-VC to the ecosystem compatibility section. The suggested response will be that we plan to address comment in future version of specification.

ivan: Any response we make is better to send via email.

brent: I will do that.

KevinDean: Is there something we can add to the response to provide reasoning? Out of scope for current scope of work?

brent: This is an editorial change, we can address it under our current charter, seeing how ideally we shouldn't change text of REC, we can address this later.

selfissued: That's fine.

iherman avatar Apr 25 '25 15:04 iherman

This was discussed during the vcwg meeting on 13 August 2025.

View the transcript

w3c/vc-data-model#1593

Brent: Add SD-JWT-VC to Ecosystem Compatibility section

<JoeAndrieu> FYI, I just closed #1599

Brent: We had a conversation about this, believe it's a class 2 as it's a list of examples.

iherman avatar Aug 17 '25 09:08 iherman