<input> rerenders while changes affects only sibling elements

[kamax1]

Version

2.5.2

Reproduction link

https://codepen.io/anon/pen/OxKqbL?editors=1111

Steps to reproduce

Please open codepen example and type something into input

What is expected?

Input should not lose focus

What is actually happening?

input rerenders and loses focus

---

happens only if there is such conditional elements exists before and after input. Workaround is to use v-show instead of v-if in such cases.

[yyx990803]

You can also simply give the <input> a key to ensure it is not replaced.

[kamax1]

i tried your solution in codepen and still cant get it working.

i tried this <input type="text" v-model="inputVal" :key="1">

[IlyaOsotov]

U need to have same DOM structure before your input. Look this. It can be after update your DOM before your input tag

[kyle7zhang]

Actually, it is the same input element, but first remove from the document then move it to other places, for example:

it first renders like

 <!----> // A
<input />
 <!----> // B

then you focus input and input some words, then virtual dom insert <span>before</span>, and it then parent.insertBefore(input, A), it moves the input element before the A comment element, so it will eventually lose focus, then it will delete the comment node.

so, I think you could use v-show better to avoid the insertBefore move problem(remove from the document then insert before the reference node, in this case, which is comment A ). This is the default action for virtual dom of vue which doesn't replace comment node.

[znck]

You can also simply give the <input> a key to ensure it is not replaced.

<input> element focus is lost in either case.

[Kingwl]

https://github.com/google/incremental-dom/issues/237
seems like this one

[Kingwl]

I have tried to fix this issue
But I encountered some problem have we got some way to access vnode from html element?
I want to get vnode path as https://github.com/google/incremental-dom/issues/237
But I did not find a good way to do that
have i missing something? or have other better solution?😅

[dev-blinov]

@Kingwl you can use v-show. It works correctly.

[furryablack]

Alternative way: https://codepen.io/furrya_black/pen/ZVVLpQ

Just html-layout usually has a more complex structure. What do you thing? As a proof you can see any css framework: material disign, bulma, bootstrap, etc (what else)

UPD: if your case require rerender-mehanic (with v-if)

[janschoenherr]

It also seems to break (loose focus) if the spans are shown initially:

https://codepen.io/janschoenherr/pen/NoJpoY?editors=1111

I would think that it doesn't need to do insertBefore in this case.

[Akryum]

Other reproductions:

https://codepen.io/adamwathan/pen/vMJrYj https://codesandbox.io/s/q9mqnjnxr9

[Akryum]

Thread on twitter

[Justineo]

F.Y.I. It seems that #9473, #9496, #9808 all share the same root cause.

[brnteka]

I'm using Vue 2.6.7 and this issue is still relevant, i was able to work it out by using v-show instead of v-if on a sibling, but it's still confusing why it doesn't work when v-if is used

[nolros]

I found that @focus is not reliable when using DOM manipulation, such as v-if and therefore, directives would be the best approach:

<template>
    <form method="POST"
          autocomplete="off"
          @submit.prevent="onSubmit">

<!--     We set the directive here v-focus with the function prop handleFocus -->
        <div class="flex mt-1 rounded-md shadow-sm">
            <input id="title"
                   type="text"
                   v-focus="handleFocus"
                   v-model="form.title">
        </div>

    </form>
</template>


<script>
        export default {
            name: "FormComponent",
            data() {
                return {
                    // A form class example, but you could just have a var
                    form: new this.$form({
                        title: null,
                    })
                }
            },
            directives: {
                focus: {
                    inserted(el,binding) {
                        // We set focus on the element
                        el.focus();
                        // optional if you had other operations. Data and props, etc. are not available inside
                        // a direective uless yoru decorate the provider, which is a pain. So we call the binding
                        // which is the handleFocus set on input. We pass the el but we could inject nothing or a event, binding, etc
                        if (!_.isUndefined(binding.value)) binding.value(el)
                    }
                }
            },
            methods: {
                handleFocus: function() {
                    // For example reset a form v-model
                    this.form.title = null;
                },
            }
        }
    </script>

[misaghkarimi]

v-show it worked thanks.

[hljeong]

I had the problem where a v-if causes the parent modal to lose focus so that pressing <esc> does not close the modal. v-show did not fix my problem since rendering the element when the v-if condition is not met results in an error due to a null value.

I worked around this by focusing an invisible dummy <Input /> in the modal whenever the v-if condition changes.