cldr icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
cldr copied to clipboard

CLDR-18117 Update subdivisionData.txt to correct province name Afyon to Afyonkarahisar

Open m-akbay opened this issue 1 year ago • 6 comments

…ahisar

CLDR-_____

  • [ ] This PR completes the ticket.

ALLOW_MANY_COMMITS=true

m-akbay avatar Nov 19 '24 07:11 m-akbay

CLA assistant check
All committers have signed the CLA.

CLAassistant avatar Nov 19 '24 07:11 CLAassistant

The current name for the province "Afyon" in subdivisionData.txt is outdated and incomplete. The official and full name of the province, as recognized in Turkish law and administrative records, is "Afyonkarahisar". This name has been in official use since 2005, following a decision to restore the historical name of the city and province.

Reason for the Update:

Consistency with Official Standards: The Turkish government and international organizations recognize the name "Afyonkarahisar" as the official designation.

Alignment with CLDR Goals: CLDR aims to provide accurate and standardized data for localization. Using the official and complete name ensures consistency and reliability in localized applications.

Avoiding Ambiguity: "Afyon" is commonly used informally, but it is not the formal or legal name. Updating the entry eliminates potential confusion for developers and end-users.

Additional Note: In the CLDR repository, all other references to this province already use the name "Afyonkarahisar". This update to subdivisionData.txt will align it with the rest of the repository, ensuring uniformity across all files and data points.

Proposed Solution:

Update the subdivision name from "Afyon" to "Afyonkarahisar" in subdivisionData.txt.

Optionally, retain "Afyon" as an alias or alternative name for backward compatibility or informal usage contexts.

This change will align CLDR with international and national standards for geographic names, improve data accuracy, and ensure consistency across the entire repository.

https://www.afyonkarahisar.gov.tr/ https://www.hurriyet.com.tr/afyonkarahisar-haberleri/ https://www.sabah.com.tr/afyonkarahisar

m-akbay avatar Nov 20 '24 12:11 m-akbay

Unfortunately we'll have to wait until 2025 to land this change -- it needs discussion in the Unicode CLDR committees on the protocol to address issues in subdivision data.

Thanks for your patience. It brought up a good issue -- but too good so it needs a broader discussion.

conradarcturus avatar Dec 04 '24 18:12 conradarcturus

No worries, no rush :) Take your time!

m-akbay avatar Dec 05 '24 16:12 m-akbay

@m-akbay We appreciate your contribution. Would you like to have your name included on the CLDR acknowledgements page? https://cldr.unicode.org/index/acknowledgments If you'd like to be added, please provide me with your full name. You can add it here or email it to [email protected]

michelleperham avatar Feb 27 '25 17:02 michelleperham

@michelleperham Thank you, I would love to be included on the acknowledgments page! Please add my full name: Mustafa Akbay.

I appreciate the work you’re doing for CLDR!

m-akbay avatar Feb 28 '25 05:02 m-akbay