"emitWithAck" function leaks memory when acknowledgement timeout

[ZhangSen1]

Describe the bug

When using "emitWithAck" on the server side, the memory is not freed when the acknowledgement timeout is reached.

I tested on 500 client connections, and the memory usage is 1557MB after 3 hours.

Steps:

1. Connect 500 clients, 10 clients per room, 50 rooms
2. The first client in each room sends a message to the room every second(use emitWithAck)
3. Each client does not call callback after receiving a message(simulation timeout)
4. Memory usage is not freed

To Reproduce

Socket.IO server version: 4.7.2

Server

try{
    const responses = await socket.timeout(2000).to("room1").emitWithAck("event", "message");
} catch(err){

}

Socket.IO client version: 4.7.2

Client

 socket.on("event", (data, callback) => {
      // Do not call callback, simulation timeout.
      // callback(1);
    });

Expected behavior

Should not leak memory

Platform:

• Server Node.js version: 18.18.0
• Client Node.js version: 18.18.0
• OS: win 10

Additional context

See broadcast-operator.ts timer, it seems that when timeout, ack function is not deleted from socket.acks.

[darrachequesne]

Hi! I could indeed reproduce the issue, thanks for the detailed analysis :+1:

Not sure how we can fix this though, let me check.

[maraujop]

Any update on this @darrachequesne ?

We are experiencing this issue often too