ffmpeg-aws-lambda-layer icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
ffmpeg-aws-lambda-layer copied to clipboard

Output video is significantly sped up

Open harterc3 opened this issue 4 years ago • 2 comments

For the project I'm working on, I'm mainly just taking mp4s recorded by users in a web browser and trying to transcode them to be manageable sizes as well as playable in all device/browser combos. I was using AWS MediaConvert for this but later found out that mobile Safari records video in a "fragmented" mp4 which is not supported by MediaConvert so I'm turning to replacing MC with an ffmpeg layer.

I've deployed the ffmpeg lambda layer from the SAR and copied most of the code from the example but for some reason all the output videos are significantly sped up. When I run the same commands with my local ffmpeg, everything works fine. Any help is appreciated!

export const onVideoUpload: Handler = Sentry.AWSLambda.wrapHandler(async (event: S3Event, context: Context) => {
  const EXTENSION = '.mp4',
	  MIME_TYPE =  'video/mp4';

  const eventRecord = event.Records && event.Records[0],
		inputBucket = eventRecord.s3.bucket.name,
		key = eventRecord.s3.object.key,
		id = context.awsRequestId,
		resultKey = key.replace(/\.[^.]+$/, EXTENSION),
		workdir = os.tmpdir(),
		inputFile = path.join(workdir,  id + path.extname(key)),
		outputFile = path.join(workdir, 'out_' + id + EXTENSION);

	console.log('converting', inputBucket, key, 'using', inputFile);
  // ffmpeg -i 2254.webm -c copy output.webm
  // ffmpeg -i input.mp4 -b:v 1M -b:a 192k output.avi
	return downloadFileFromS3(inputBucket, key, inputFile)
		.then(() => childProcess(
			'/opt/bin/ffmpeg',
			['-i', inputFile, '-b:v', '1M', '-b:a', '192k', '-nostdin', outputFile],
			{env: process.env, cwd: workdir}
		))
		.then(() => uploadFileToS3(process.env['DestinationBucket']!, resultKey, outputFile, MIME_TYPE));
});

harterc3 avatar Aug 10 '21 16:08 harterc3

maybe try without the explicit bitrate (-b:v)?

gojko avatar Aug 11 '21 08:08 gojko

Updated the function to

return downloadFileFromS3(inputBucket, key, inputFile)
  .then(() => childProcess(
    '/opt/bin/ffmpeg',
    ['-i', inputFile, '-nostdin', outputFile],
    {env: process.env, cwd: workdir}
  ))
  .then(() => uploadFileToS3(process.env['DestinationBucket']!, resultKey, outputFile, MIME_TYPE));

and I still have the same result: https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/3442109/129050132-b7da97c1-217a-4631-9919-68606fd9c6d5.mp4

Original video: https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/3442109/129050443-78463553-4fda-43a7-81ce-6bf04aa36e1d.mp4

harterc3 avatar Aug 11 '21 14:08 harterc3