Multiple type applications on overloaded method crashes scalac

[diesalbla]

There is a corner case that occurs in the intersection of type application and method overloading.

The following program shows an object A with an overloaded method a, in both cases with a simple type parameter F, with different arguments.

object A {
    def a[F](x: Int) = 0
    def a[F](x: String) = 0
}
A.a[Int][String](0)

In the final line, when the method is applied with two lists of type arguments, the compiler crashes with a java.lang.ClassCastException.

Note that, as explained in #6729, this is not a syntax problem. There can be applications with several lists of type parameters, such as when the result of one is an object with an def apply[F] method.

Similar programs that do not crash the compiler are the following ones:

• If you remove the type parameters F.
• If you only have one method a (no overloading)
• If you apply the method a to a single list of several parameters A.a[Int, String](42) .

[hrhino]

The stack trace is telling:

scala> A.a[Int][Int](0)
java.lang.ClassCastException: scala.reflect.internal.Types$PolyType cannot be cast to scala.reflect.internal.Types$OverloadedType
        at scala.reflect.internal.Symbols$Symbol.alternatives(Symbols.scala:1941)
        at scala.reflect.internal.Symbols$Symbol.filter(Symbols.scala:1947)
        at scala.tools.nsc.typechecker.Infer$Inferencer.inferPolyAlternatives(Infer.scala:1423)
        at scala.tools.nsc.typechecker.Typers$Typer.typedTypeApply(Typers.scala:4025)
        at scala.tools.nsc.typechecker.Typers$Typer.typedTypeApply$1(Typers.scala:5344)
        at scala.tools.nsc.typechecker.Typers$Typer.typedOutsidePatternMode$1(Typers.scala:5507)

Nice find!

[Jasper-M]

This also crashes the compiler in cases that should compile.

scala> :pa
// Entering paste mode (ctrl-D to finish)

class Apply { def apply[A](x: Int) = 1 }

object A {
    def a[F] = new Apply
    def a[F](x: String) = 0
}

// Exiting paste mode, now interpreting.

defined class Apply
defined object A

scala> A.a[String]("a")
res2: Int = 0

scala> A.a[String](3)
res3: Int = 1

scala> A.a[String][Int](3)
java.lang.ClassCastException

[dimitarg]

This caused some considerable head scratching today, I wrote

val paymentTermCodec = enumOf[PaymentTerm][42]

:boom:

whereas I meant to write

val paymentTermCodec = enumOf[PaymentTerm](42)

(where enumOf has overloads with len: Int and underlying: Codec)

Not sure how Diego came up with their example, but above is at least one piece of anecdotal evidence it can come up in practice.

[SethTisue]

closed PR a volunteer could try to finish: https://github.com/scala/scala/pull/10832

[som-snytt]

Auntie Polly will thank you.

[joroKr21]

Why is the first alternative treated specially? I don't get the purpose of this code.

      // Alternatives which conform to bounds
      def checkWithinBounds(sym: Symbol): Unit = sym.alternatives match {
        case Nil            => if (!argtypes.exists(_.isErroneous)) fail()
        case alt :: Nil     => finish(alt, pre memberType alt)
        case alts @ hd :: _ =>
          log(s"Attaching AntiPolyType-carrying overloaded type to $sym")
          // Multiple alternatives which are within bounds; spin up an
          // overloaded type which carries an "AntiPolyType" as a prefix.
          val tparams = new AsSeenFromMap(pre, hd.owner) mapOver hd.typeParams
          val bounds  = tparams map (_.tpeHK) // see e.g., #1236
          val tpe     = PolyType(tparams, OverloadedType(AntiPolyType(pre, bounds), alts))
          finish(sym setInfo tpe, tpe)
      }

[som-snytt]

I observe that changing the test pos/t1236 adding an upper bound and switching the order

  //def foo[F[_]](q: (String, String)) = "hello"
  def foo[F[_]](e: Empty[F]) = "world"
  def foo[F[_] <: List[_]](q: (String, String)) = "hello"

  val x = foo[List](ListEmpty)

shows the AntiPolyType still around at UnCurry.

My loose understanding was that it simply assists in providing an expected type for args while typing. (We know the alternatives take F[_] and the applied arg is List.) Once you look up the member type, you don't see APT any more, which is only for the overload.

        at scala.reflect.internal.Types$PolyType.mapOver(Types.scala:3028)
        at scala.reflect.internal.transform.UnCurry$$anon$1.apply(UnCurry.scala:71)