arduino-CAN icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
arduino-CAN copied to clipboard
verified publisher icon sandeepmistry

Is this lib dead?

Open Jojo-A opened this issue 2 years ago • 6 comments

Hi,

I see that this lib has a lot of really great PRs pending which include serious bug fixes and a lot of performance improvements. Especially the PRs from @timurrrr. Many issues are unanswered as well as many topic in the discussions. The last commits cover minor changes (link fix... WHO CARES?!?), no real improvements.

So: is this lib dead?!? Maybe it should be removed from the Arduino list or replaced by a better maintained fork?

Jojo-A avatar Jan 31 '23 11:01 Jojo-A

Hi @Jojo-A. Did you found a maintained alternative?

thalesmaoa avatar May 29 '23 21:05 thalesmaoa

Hi @thalesmaoa , I personally use the fork from @timurrrr here: https://github.com/timurrrr/arduino-CAN The last commit in that fork is long ago, indeed. But I had direct contact to him and you also can see, that there are no open pull requests as well as no open (relevant) issues. It runs rock-stable in my application.

Jojo-A avatar May 30 '23 07:05 Jojo-A

Thanks, I will try it. Probably the bug I've noticed is not present there.

thalesmaoa avatar May 30 '23 13:05 thalesmaoa

It runs rock-stable in my application.

Are you using VScode + Platformio? What platform version?

After hours of investigation, I found that using a version of platform-espressif32 newer than 3.5.0 (and 4.2.0 in another case) makes the ESP32 reboot in a loop when connected to a CANBUS network (95kbps). Using ESP32 devkitC v1 and v4 along with SN65HVD230 transceiver combo.

A simple sniffing sketch like this makes the device reboot in a loop: https://github.com/adamtheone/canDrive/tree/main/01_canSniffer_Arduino

Recent versions of the Arduino IDE (2.x) have the same bad outcome. Arduino IDE 1.8.19 (and platform-espressif32 @ 3.5.0) work fine.

zalexzperez avatar Jul 15 '23 23:07 zalexzperez

Are you using VScode + Platformio? What platform version?

Oh, this is some time ago already. I just used Arduino IDE v2.0.3 and the BSP for esp8266 3.1.1 and the BSP for ESP32 2.0.6 (iirc). Please open another issue to discuss your bootloop problem. I started this issue to find out how good (or bad) this lib is maintained.

Jojo-A avatar Jul 18 '23 09:07 Jojo-A

This issue helped to solve my problem. I was pulling out my hair for 6 hours with 2 esp32 wroom module connected with MCP2551 transceiver chip. And I finally came across this issue.

The fork mentioned worked out of the box. https://github.com/timurrrr/arduino-CAN

Anyway thanks for this wonderful Library.

elementzonline avatar Oct 12 '23 16:10 elementzonline