safe-core-sdk icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
safe-core-sdk copied to clipboard

[SDK Refactoring] ESM Modules

Open yagopv opened this issue 2 years ago • 1 comments
trafficstars

Context / issue

Using current node engines with esm modules is difficult and require some hacks as we are compiling safe-core-sdk using commonjs

With esm, import and export declarations are determined statically at compile time. This static structure allows for better tooling with things like tree shaking (dead code elimination), faster lookup, and advanced optimizations.

Consequences of supporting only commonjs

  • In Browsers: Browser based applications that want to use out SDK will need to transpile the code, which adds an additional step to their build process
  • Compatibility: Modern libraries and applications that prefer or require esm modules might face difficulties integrating with our SDK
  • Tree Shaking: esm enables effective tree shaking, which is important for reducing the final bundle size in frontend applications. commonjs does not support tree shaking efficiently.

By offering both formats, we can ensure wider compatibility and make the SDK more attractive to a broader range of developers and projects.

Proposed solution

The proposed solution would compile safe-core-sdk with a dual output with both commonjs and esm modules being distributed inside the package

Additional context

First issue Similar solution in safe-apps-sdk Issue with Safe.create

yagopv avatar Aug 29 '23 09:08 yagopv

I think I ran into a related bug: when using dynamic imports with this lib, we get a nested 'default' prop. To illustrate:

export async function getSafeApiClient({ chainId }: { chainId: number }): Promise<ISafeApiKit> {

  const imported = await import('@safe-global/api-kit');
  const SafeApiKit = imported.default.default || imported.default;
}

And it depends on how we're running it, so it could be our configuration. If I run the code with ts-node or Next.js, the issue does not happen. If I use esbuild or tsx, then it is nested inside an extra default prop

mattcasey avatar Apr 11 '24 19:04 mattcasey