osmose-backend icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
osmose-backend copied to clipboard

Improper warning for aerialway=zip_line

Open Schroecker opened this issue 2 years ago • 2 comments

item/class 9001001 missing tag usage without railway or waterway i.E. for way 604738413 Please complement "usage" for aerialway=zip_line

Schroecker avatar Nov 11 '23 11:11 Schroecker

Hello,

This validation warning originates from JOSM (specifically, this part of their code). We import these rules from JOSM into Osmose. Could you please report it to them? You can report it here: https://josm.openstreetmap.de/newticket

In order to stop this warning, they should change

way[usage][!railway][!waterway][route!=railway][man_made!=pipeline] {

to

way[usage][!railway][!waterway][route!=railway][man_made!=pipeline][!aerialway] {

In addition, although the use of usage=* is documented on the wikis of Key:aerialway, Tag:aerialway=zip_line and several others for many years with the intention to deprecate the unspecific tag aerialway=goods, it is not documented on the wiki of Key:usage itself

Famlam avatar Nov 11 '23 14:11 Famlam

Thank you for filing https://josm.openstreetmap.de/ticket/23298 !

Famlam avatar Nov 14 '23 12:11 Famlam

In 19165/josm:

Fix #23298: Improper warning for aerialway=zip_line

Exclude aerialway from combinations check and add usage values to aerialway presets (where someone has already used the key with the aerialway tag).

tsmock avatar Aug 05 '24 17:08 tsmock

Deployed, thanks @tsmock

Famlam avatar Aug 12 '24 21:08 Famlam