nostr icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
nostr copied to clipboard

Inconsistency in comparison with Mastodon

Open tobyink opened this issue 2 years ago • 3 comments

https://github.com/nostr-protocol/nostr/blob/cdcc98f53c8c67d5efe80a11da121abf7995b698/README.md?plain=1#L35

There are no clear incentives to run servers

But the three bullet points directly above this line each are examples of clear incentives to run servers:

  • User identities are attached to domain names
  • Server owners can ban you, just like Twitter; Server owners can also block other servers;
  • Migration between servers is an afterthought and can only be accomplished if servers cooperate.

tobyink avatar Feb 28 '23 10:02 tobyink

You're basically saying that Mastodon works if every person run their own server, which I agree with.

fiatjaf avatar Feb 28 '23 11:02 fiatjaf

Well, it's a trade-off like with other decentralized services such as HTTP and SMTP.

If you run your own server, you're not subject to someone else's whims and you have more freedom about how you manage it and how you configure things. If you delegate hosting to somebody else, it's more convenient, but you're at their mercy. Depending on what you value, you'll go one path or the other, or somewhere in between.

tobyink avatar Feb 28 '23 16:02 tobyink

You're basically saying that Mastodon works if every person run their own server, which I agree with.

https://start9labs.medium.com/new-service-mastodon-9af10df5615 :grin:

spencerflagg avatar Feb 28 '23 20:02 spencerflagg