NIP-34 Relay Supported Features

[Semisol]

Very simple NIP, adds supported_features to the relay information document that is an array of strings such as:

• nip1.limit
• dev.semisol.search

[fiatjaf]

I understand why you want this, but I don't think the argument is sound enough.

Ideally we should do more with less, and NIP-11 has already a ton of unused features. I think they could be used for your purposes -- or, alternatively we should remove stuff from it and replace with these newer things here.

I would also want to see an actual concrete real-world use case.

[jb55]

I'm confused, nip-11 already defines supported_nips, isn't this the same thing being proposed here?

[Semisol]

I would also want to see an actual concrete real-world use case.

If a NIP is edited or extended you cannot detect that. You cannot also do partial implementation of NIPs since clients assume you implemented it all or none

[fiatjaf]

I understand the arguments, but these are not actual concrete real-world use cases. Or maybe I chose the wrong words. I want an actual situation.