FMODGMS icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
FMODGMS copied to clipboard

Issues with DLS and Midi extracted with VGMTrans

Open LuigiXHero opened this issue 8 years ago • 5 comments

I'm trying to play a Persona 1 song and a Mario and Luigi: Partner's in time song. I converted the original PS1/NDS formatted files into Midi with DLS, They sound perfect when played in a player, however when playing them using this plugin they sound messed up. Songs in question.zip

LuigiXHero avatar Aug 01 '17 21:08 LuigiXHero

Hi,

I'm a a bit busy with work right now, but I'll look into it as soon as I can.

mstop4 avatar Aug 07 '17 15:08 mstop4

Awesome, glad to see this is still being worked on and I hope this is fixed.

LuigiXHero avatar Aug 16 '17 02:08 LuigiXHero

I tried to play the MIDI files with the DLS banks you sent and they are also not playing correctly on my end. Do you know if the banks are DLS1 or DLS2? FMOD Studio only supports the older DLS Level 1 spec.

mstop4 avatar Oct 21 '17 03:10 mstop4

I honestly have no clue.

LuigiXHero avatar Jul 31 '18 07:07 LuigiXHero

Based on the information I could find on VGMTrans, I think it generates DLS2 banks, which aren't supported by FMOD. Based on some threads on I dug up on the FMOD forums from a decade ago, I don't think adding DLS2 support is a priority for them.

mstop4 avatar Aug 02 '18 19:08 mstop4