msgpack-go icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
msgpack-go copied to clipboard

Deprecate msgpack-go (in favor of go-msgpack)

Open moriyoshi opened this issue 12 years ago • 9 comments

As msgpack-go is no longer actively maintained mainly because of the original developer being a way too busy to pay attention (kudos to @methane and all the guys having worked on it), I think it's time to start thinking of deprecating msgpack-go and possibly embracing a great alternative, go-msgpack (please supply any if there are more) as a new, official Go implementation of msgpack.

moriyoshi avatar Mar 04 '13 12:03 moriyoshi

@ugorji ping

moriyoshi avatar Mar 04 '13 12:03 moriyoshi

+1. I already suggest in README

methane avatar Mar 04 '13 12:03 methane

+1 @moriyoshi , I appreciate all your work so far. @ugorji, I look forward to your further initiatives on go-msgpack.

ymotongpoo avatar Mar 04 '13 12:03 ymotongpoo

@ugorji i personally discussed with @frsyuki about moving your go-msgpack implementation under msgpack organization. Because both @methane and @moriyoshi accepted this migration, all i need to say is: please be msgpack committer to have better and improve golang implementation :)

kzk avatar Mar 04 '13 13:03 kzk

As a separate note, @ugorji's implementation also has some forks. > https://github.com/ugorji/go-msgpack/network

to avoid the fragmentation, it would be better to notice them about this migration.

kzk avatar Mar 04 '13 13:03 kzk

Hi folks.

Yes, I will be delighted to contribute go-msgpack as a de-facto Go implementation.

I've done some refactoring to the code to make it easier to follow while still keeping the feature set. I'd like to clean it up some more over the next few days, then make an update.

When that is done, would you like me to update the msgpack wiki?

However, if it's alright with you folks, I'd like to leave it under go-msgpack (just like with the node, lua and javascript libraries). I'm hoping that will encourage me to stay on top of it, and improve collaboration.

Side question: Has anyone thought about using github pages to host the site? I just realized the pages feature and it looks pretty cool.

ugorji avatar Mar 05 '13 10:03 ugorji

@ugorji i'll coordinate the process including github pages. could you give me your mail address? mine is [email protected]

However, if it's alright with you folks, I'd like to leave it under go-msgpack (just like with the node, lua and javascript libraries). I'm hoping that will encourage me to stay on top of it, and improve collaboration.

Sorry, what do you mean? You want to have respository name as go-msgpack, instead of msgpack-go...?

kzk avatar Mar 06 '13 23:03 kzk

Hi @kzk,

I meant that I would like to keep it at the current location, as opposed to moving it under the msgpack, as opposed to moving it under the msgpack user in github.

Got your email. I'd send you one now so you'd have mine.

ugorji avatar Mar 07 '13 15:03 ugorji

The README.md for go-msgpack says:

DEPRECATED as of May 29, 2013. Please use github.com/ugorji/go/codec which is significantly faster, cleaner, more correct and more complete. See [https://github.com/ugorji/go/tree/master/codec#readme]

Perhaps the README for this project should be updated as well?

xyproto avatar Jun 19 '13 11:06 xyproto