get returns all fields, select provides values, all non selected fields returned with 'None' value

[dogrileycom]

Environment

• Python Version: 3.11.6
• msgraph-core version: 1.0.0.a4
• OS: MacOS 14.2.1 M2

Stack trace (if available) Screenshot or formatted copy and paste of your stack trace.

Describe the bug formatting a select statement

query_params = UsersRequestBuilder.UsersRequestBuilderGetQueryParameters(
    select=['id', 'accountEnabled', 'businessPhones', 'city', 'companyName', 'country', 'createdDateTime',
            'deletedDateTime', 'department', 'displayName', 'employeeId', 'givenName', 'jobTitle',
            'mail', 'mailNickname', 'mobilePhone', 'officeLocation', 'postalCode', 'preferredDataLocation',
                'preferredLanguage', 'securityIdentifier', 'state', 'streetAddress', 'surname', 'userPrincipalName',
                'userType'],
    orderby= "displayName",
    top=1
    )
    
    request_configuration = UsersRequestBuilder.UsersRequestBuilderGetRequestConfiguration(
    query_parameters=query_params
    )
    request_configuration.headers.add('ConsistencyLevel', 'eventual')
users = await client.users.get(request_configuration = request_configuration)

This returns:

UserCollectionResponse(
	additional_data={'@odata.context': 'https://graph.microsoft.com/v1.0/$metadata#users(id,accountEnabled,businessPhones,city,companyName,country,createdDateTime,deletedDateTime,department,displayName,employeeId,givenName,jobTitle,mail,mailNickname,mobilePhone,officeLocation,postalCode,preferredDataLocation,preferredLanguage,securityIdentifier,state,streetAddress,surname,userPrincipalName,userType)'}, 
	odata_count=17, 
	odata_next_link='https://graph.microsoft.com/v1.0/users?$top=1&$count=true&$orderby=displayName&$select=id%2caccountEnabled%2cbusinessPhones%2ccity%2ccompanyName%2ccountry%2ccreatedDateTime%2cdeletedDateTime%2cdepartment%2cdisplayName%2cemployeeId%2cgivenName%2cjobTitle%2cmail%2cmailNickname%2cmobilePhone%2cofficeLocation%2cpostalCode%2cpreferredDataLocation%2cpreferredLanguage%2csecurityIdentifier%2cstate%2cstreetAddress%2csurname%2cuserPrincipalName%2cuserType&$skiptoken=m~AQC4ATs7MzAwMDQ1MDAzMDAwMzIwMDMwMDA0NTAwMzEwMDQxMDAzMDAwNDUwMDMyMDAzMTAwMzAwMDQ1MDAzNDAwMzgwMDMwMDA0NTAwMzIwMDMxMDAzMDAwMzcwMDMwMDAzMjAwMzAwMDQ1MDA0MTAwMzIwMDMwMDA0NTAwMzAwMDMyMDAzMDAwNDUwMDM3MDAzMDAwMzAwMDQ1MDAzMDAwNDEwMDMwMDA0NTAwMzIwMDMxMDA7MTswOzs', 
	value=[
		User(
			additional_data={}, 
			id='4421ec16-6e81-436e-b765-8ab20ef1fdc7', 
			odata_type='#microsoft.graph.user', 
			deleted_date_time=None, 
			about_me=None, 
			account_enabled=True, 
			activities=None, 
			age_group=None, 
			agreement_acceptances=None, 
			app_role_assignments=None, 
			assigned_licenses=None, 
			assigned_plans=None, 
			authentication=None, 
			authorization_info=None, 
			birthday=None, 
			business_phones=['+1 425 555 0109'], 
			calendar=None, 
			calendar_groups=None, 
			calendar_view=None, 
			calendars=None, 
			chats=None, 
			city='Bellevue', 
			company_name=None, 
			consent_provided_for_minor=None, 
			contact_folders=None, 
			contacts=None, 
			country='United States', 
			created_date_time=DateTime(2023, 11, 7, 11, 32, 41, tzinfo=Timezone('UTC')), 
			created_objects=None, 
			creation_type=None, 
			custom_security_attributes=None, 
			department='Retail', 
			device_enrollment_limit=None, 
			device_management_troubleshooting_events=None, 
			direct_reports=None, 
			display_name='Adele Vance', 
			drive=None, 
			drives=None, 
			employee_experience=None, 
			employee_hire_date=None, 
			employee_id=None, 
			employee_leave_date_time=None, 
			employee_org_data=None, 
			employee_type=None, 
			events=None, 
			extensions=None, 
			external_user_state=None, 
			external_user_state_change_date_time=None, 
			fax_number=None, 
			followed_sites=None, 
			given_name='Adele', 
			hire_date=None, 
			identities=None, 
			im_addresses=None, 
			inference_classification=None, 
			insights=None, 
			interests=None, 
			is_resource_account=None, 
			job_title='Retail Manager', 
			joined_teams=None, 
			last_password_change_date_time=None, 
			legal_age_group_classification=None, 
			license_assignment_states=None, 
			license_details=None, 
			mail='[email protected]', 
			mail_folders=None, 
			mail_nickname='AdeleV', 
			mailbox_settings=None, 
			managed_app_registrations=None, 
			managed_devices=None, 
			manager=None, 
			member_of=None, 
			messages=None, 
			mobile_phone=None, 
			my_site=None, 
			oauth2_permission_grants=None, 
			office_location='18/2111', 
			on_premises_distinguished_name=None, 
			on_premises_domain_name=None, 
			on_premises_extension_attributes=None, 
			on_premises_immutable_id=None, 
			on_premises_last_sync_date_time=None, 
			on_premises_provisioning_errors=None, 
			on_premises_sam_account_name=None, 
			on_premises_security_identifier=None, 
			on_premises_sync_enabled=None, 
			on_premises_user_principal_name=None, 
			onenote=None, 
			online_meetings=None, 
			other_mails=None, 
			outlook=None, 
			owned_devices=None, 
			owned_objects=None, 
			password_policies=None, 
			password_profile=None, 
			past_projects=None, 
			people=None, 
			photo=None, 
			photos=None, 
			planner=None, 
			postal_code='98004', 
			preferred_data_location=None, 
			preferred_language='en-US', 
			preferred_name=None, 
			presence=None, 
			print=None, 
			provisioned_plans=None, 
			proxy_addresses=None, 
			registered_devices=None, 
			responsibilities=None, 
			schools=None, 
			scoped_role_member_of=None, 
			security_identifier='S-1-12-1-1143073814-1131410721-2995414453-3355308302', 
			service_provisioning_errors=None, 
			settings=None, 
			show_in_address_list=None, 
			sign_in_activity=None, 
			sign_in_sessions_valid_from_date_time=None, 
			skills=None, 
			state='WA', 
			street_address='205 108th Ave. NE, Suite 400', 
			surname='Vance', 
			teamwork=None, 
			todo=None, 
			transitive_member_of=None, 
			usage_location=None, 
			user_principal_name='[email protected]', 
			user_type='Member'
			)
		]
	)

To Reproduce Use the code above, it works across every object I have used so far.

Expected behavior I would expect to just get the 26 fields I selected.

Screenshots If applicable, add screenshots to help explain your problem.

Additional context Add any other context about the problem here.

[Ndiritu]

Hi @dogrileycom, thanks for reaching out. This happens because we're initialising a User object whose properties default to None. The HTTP response only returns the selected fields.

Would you mind sharing more context/a use-case where you'd prefer an object with only the 26 fields?

[svrooij]

In the Graph SDK all properties are marked as Optional[type] which have None as value of unset.

To me seeing all those fields with a None value is exactly what I would expect if I don't select them. All models are strong typed User in this case. I guess you @dogrileycom were expecting to get a dynamic object or dictionary to be returned?

[microsoft-github-policy-service[bot]]

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has been marked as requiring author feedback but has not had any activity for 4 days. It will be closed if no further activity occurs within 3 days of this comment.