tolerant-php-parser icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
tolerant-php-parser copied to clipboard

Implement RecursiveIterator

Open felixfbecker opened this issue 8 years ago • 5 comments
trafficstars

PHP has native interfaces and classes for Iterators (Generator implements Iterator). Iterators can be traversed with foreach and composed easily, for example by filtering through CallbackFilterIterator.

In particular, it has the RecursiveIterator interface, that adds two more methods to implement: hasChildren() and getChildren(). This allows it to be traversed with a RecursiveIteratorIterator, which has countless options for emitting all nodes or just leaves, using level order, etc. ParentIterator can be used to visit just nodes with child nodes, RecursiveLimitIterator to limit the nodes traversed, AppendIterator to concatenate Iterators, RecursiveTreeIterator can be used to draw an ASCII tree of an AST and RecursiveCallbackFilterIterator to filter nodes (including skipping children). Really a lot of awesome stuff in there.

The Parser already uses Generators for traversal, which is great, but it only has limited options for filtering and skipping certain children through a callback: https://sourcegraph.com/github.com/Microsoft/tolerant-php-parser/-/blob/src/Node.php#L158-159 I think providing class-based implementations for Iterators would give greater flexibility.

felixfbecker avatar Jun 03 '17 11:06 felixfbecker

Actually, that was my idea creating a pr, after the pr has been merged. But you are stealing my ideas constantly. :D

jens1o avatar Jun 03 '17 11:06 jens1o

Well, go ahead. Don't let me keep you :)

felixfbecker avatar Jun 03 '17 11:06 felixfbecker

@roblourens Are you fine with this change? I would start getting on this.

jens1o avatar Jun 09 '17 20:06 jens1o

@jens1o Already almost finished ;)

felixfbecker avatar Jun 09 '17 20:06 felixfbecker

Sorry, so you had implemented that already? Okay. Then I search for other things :D

jens1o avatar Jun 09 '17 20:06 jens1o