line-of-sight icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
line-of-sight copied to clipboard

Bad Math

Open simplymathematics opened this issue 6 years ago • 1 comments

  • Fresnel Zones describe how radio waves propagate between two points. This model uses a straight line. Radio waves are not lasers. Your model will systematically give you mostly false positives and negatives.

  • A proper implementation already exists. Below, I have linked an appropriate model. https://github.com/Cloud-RF/Signal-Server/blob/master/models/itm.cc

  • It's already pretty trivial to draw a line on google earth, even for non-technical users. Seva built a tool for this like 3 years ago, but it suffered from the same laser problem.

  • This works if you want to eliminate 90% of your actually possible connections while simultaneously overestimating the capacity of links that pass close to buildings.

simplymathematics avatar May 05 '19 22:05 simplymathematics

You can probably email cloud-rf and they'll pre-compute this for you. It's probably not appropriate to do it at run time since NYC's 1 million buildings will cause interactions in complicated and unexpected ways.

Source: Bsc in Mathematics, Ms in Data Science, master's thesis in building localization models for wireless networks.

simplymathematics avatar May 05 '19 22:05 simplymathematics