illegal-use-of-OpenStreetMap icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
illegal-use-of-OpenStreetMap copied to clipboard

Check whatever Instagram app for Android is using OSM maps without a proper attribution

Open matkoniecz opened this issue 6 years ago • 4 comments

Has anybody got an access to an Instagram account and can check whatever it is part of the problem?

Things to check

  • [ ] are there any maps or geographic data in this app?
  • [ ] is it from OSM? (or there is nothing that could be from OSM)
  • [ ] is it clearly credited to OSM? (or there are no OSM data used)
  • [ ] can you take a screenshot and share it here? (or confirm that this app seems to not be using OSM data without attribution?)

matkoniecz avatar Nov 29 '19 14:11 matkoniecz

Instagram DOES use OSM. When viewing a location where a photo was tagged at, it displays a map at the top of the screen. There is a small ℹ (information) button in the corner which I personally found very hard to press. Pressing on the map itself opens in whichever map app the user's mobile device has installed.

Press on a user's photo location: Insta - East Point Lighthouse

Press on "More Information": Insta - East Point Lighthouse - More

Press on the small info button in the corner: Insta - East Point Lighthouse - Info

This attribution page links to the following site: https://m.facebook.com/maps/attribution_terms/.

In summary:

  • [x] are there any maps or geographic data in this app?
  • [x] is it from OSM? (or there is nothing that could be from OSM)
  • [ ] is it clearly credited to OSM? (or there are no OSM data used)
  • [x] can you take a screenshot and share it here? (or confirm that this app seems to not be using OSM data without attribution?)

ForgottenHero avatar Dec 10 '20 15:12 ForgottenHero

Thanks for checking! I will add it, hopefully soon.

matkoniecz avatar Dec 10 '20 15:12 matkoniecz

Reports that Instagram have updated their map again: https://techcrunch.com/2022/07/19/instagram-new-searchable-map-experience/

Still OpenStreetMap?

Firefishy avatar Jul 20 '22 21:07 Firefishy

Yes, Instagram is still using OSM.

  1. From a post, tap on the location.
  2. This presents the map.
  3. There is an info icon in the bottom left of the map (previously in the bottom right corner).
  4. Tap the info icon.
  5. You are presented with the following text (links in brackets added by me):

Map information Report a problem with the map (https://www.openstreetmap.org/fixthemap) Map data legal notices (https://m.facebook.com/maps/attribution_terms/) © OpenStreetMap (https://www.openstreetmap.org/copyright)

image

Here's a recording if it helps at all: https://youtube.com/shorts/UTa0aFIXdT0

I suppose what I've just found on desktop would probably be another issue altogether but there appears to be no attribution when viewed on desktop if using dark mode. As an example I found a post with Brisbane as the location. It took me here: https://www.instagram.com/explore/locations/213570382/brisbane-queensland-australia/ This is what I saw: image

You cannot interact with the map at all (no panning, zooming, or clicking). While in dark mode (built-in dark mode offered by Instagram, not a 3rd party extension) I could barely make out the info button. When I clicked it, the text isn't even visible. Poor UX decisions aside, it's the same menu as on mobile. image

Swapping to light mode resolves the visibility issue. image

ForgottenHero avatar Mar 01 '23 13:03 ForgottenHero