feat: Appearance tab re-design

[sapoepsilon]

trafficstars

• [ ] Create a macos theme that looks exactly like MacOS' native tab switcher
  • [x] auto appearance change alt-tab:

mac-os native:

• [ ] Change appearance settings tab view
  • [ ] Group by themes
  • [ ] Create individual settings for each theme

Figma link

[lwouis]

Hi @sapoepsilon,

Thank you for sharing this PR! Today i start moving out to a new place. So please forgive me if it takes a while until i can review it 🙇‍♂️

Hopefully next week i can do a review.

Thank you

[sapoepsilon]

Hi @sapoepsilon,

Thank you for sharing this PR! Today i start moving out to a new place. So please forgive me if it takes a while until i can review it 🙇‍♂️

Hopefully next week i can do a review.

Thank you

Take your time! This PR is WIP and will probably take me weeks to fully implement the full redesign. At this stage is more of a POC.

Good luck with moving. That's always a pain!

[AlejandroVolkova]

I was about to submit the same request since the only issue I have with my AltTab setup is the theme color because it's always in dark mode, but I'm happy to see @lwouis is open to making it, anyways here are some screenshots of my configuration.

[sapoepsilon]

Hey @lwouis, I am struggling here a bit. I am trying to align a new TabView in the Appearance tab of the Preferences Window. However, whenever I am shifting a MacOS theme with one element in it the TabView is shifting to the bottom. Have you encountered this kinda issue?

[lwouis]

@sapoepsilon i'm afraid it's a classic AppKit layout issue. I've spent countless hours on such issues.

We still have a few open issues users get into on older macOS releases for instance. In addition, there have been layout conflict warnings in the logs for many years, and i haven't been able to remove them. As far as i can tell, the preference window with its header of buttons at the top is bugged straight from the SDK. Unless we would re-implement it from scratch, it's literally bugged from the SDK at the internal level. That's for the warnings.

in your case, it's probably the layout engine not figuring out what to do. It's about trial and error in my experience. AppKit has 3 layout systems that were introduced over the years, and all 3 exist on top of each other. I invite you to look at guides to go more in depth on the topic.

If you prefer, feel free to throw away a lot of the current approach and write something better, for the layout part of the preferences tabs.

[sapoepsilon]

Sounds good! Will experiment with the UI, then! Thank you for the advise.

[lwouis]

@sapoepsilon some extra tips:

• Don't hesitate to use this. It will add an overlay on the windows when it detects conflicts. This is in addition to what AppKit already logs in that regards, when you launch the app and open windows.
• You can add a symbolic breakpoint to help debug layout issues
  
• The overlap between the various layout system can be tamed by using some of these methods:
  • translatesAutoresizingMaskIntoConstraints
  • Using contraints with contraint(...).isActive = true (example)
  • Positionning things "manually" with frame, frame.width/frame.height, setFrame, setFrameOrigin, setContentSize, etc.

[lwouis]

Some of the long-lasting issues I've mentioned: https://github.com/lwouis/alt-tab-macos/issues/1062, https://github.com/lwouis/alt-tab-macos/issues/814, https://github.com/lwouis/alt-tab-macos/issues/2663 and https://github.com/lwouis/alt-tab-macos/issues/1279

[sapoepsilon]

Some of the long-lasting issues I've mentioned: https://github.com/lwouis/alt-tab-macos/issues/1062, https://github.com/lwouis/alt-tab-macos/issues/814, https://github.com/lwouis/alt-tab-macos/issues/2663 and https://github.com/lwouis/alt-tab-macos/issues/1279

Those are interesting issues. Will tackle them down too. This is awesome, thanks!

[lwouis]

Hi @sapoepsilon,

I was able to review this work a bit today. I ran the app, but it seems that the preference UI is not yet changed in a usable way.

I think the state of this MR is work-in-progress, right? I mean that it's still a bit far away from the Figma, right?

Please let me know when you've made more progress, and I'll check it out again 👍

Thank you

[sapoepsilon]

Hi @sapoepsilon,

I was able to review this work a bit today. I ran the app, but it seems that the preference UI is not yet changed in a usable way.

I think the state of this MR is work-in-progress, right? I mean that it's still a bit far away from the Figma, right?

Please let me know when you've made more progress, and I'll check it out again 👍

Thank you

Hello @lwouis , yes, it is still in work in progress.

I have made a little more progress in my fork, and have not committed it here yet. Also, my school has started(last semester) and I have been neglecting this project for the last couple of weeks. As soon as I figure out my time management, I will be back to active contributions.

I, initially, planned that the work be done in 2 weeks(ha-ha), but I think I would be done by January next year with my current schedule.

[jacksongoode]

Hoping we can see a redesign :)

[sapoepsilon]

Hoping we can see a redesign :)

I will resume my work in November. I'm projecting it to be done by January.

[conker-rsc]

This will be a lifesaver given the recent Sonoma updates - thank you for your efforts on this!

[sapoepsilon]

Update maybe?

Hey, I’ve been thinking about finishing up the work this summer. Sorry, I got really busy with work and school.

[AlejandroVolkova]

I don’t mean to sound rude or complain, but I wish someone could fully commit to moving things forward, it's been a long time and unfortunately still there's no advancement in this matter, Maybe involving the app owner could help move things forward

[lwouis]

@AlejandroVolkova pinned issue: #1179