lucaschessR icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
lucaschessR copied to clipboard

Pawn piece in move announcement

Open dlbbld opened this issue 3 years ago • 3 comments

If one records the pawn piece, the move announcement speaks the pawn piece. e4 becomes "pawn e4", not simply "e4". But that is not speaking the SAN. If one does not know the connection between recording, one cannot get rid of this!

I suggest either removing recording the pawn piece (and so speaking it) or making this a more transparent feature.

That would be accomplished by not speaking the pawn piece by default, also if recorded. Instead, add a checkbox on Config / Options if to speak it, and if so, point out if not yet recorded. That is more of an option for beginners. I am not sure if it helps that much. Just to mention the idea. Speaking the LAN is much more helpful for beginners.

dlbbld avatar Feb 10 '22 22:02 dlbbld

Because I sometimes use a DGT board, I focus on the move announcement. Even for beginners, I think it is better not to announce the pawn piece as it is not according to the SAN. Only if explicitly wished.

dlbbld avatar Feb 20 '22 18:02 dlbbld

I have removed it.

lukasmonk avatar Feb 20 '22 23:02 lukasmonk

Thanks. Just for illustration, this is how the DGT windows driver (which is getting outdated) has implemented the option of speaking the pawn piece. But personally, I don't think that much helps a beginner. So as such without pawn piece, it is straightforward to use.

DGT RabbitPlugin

dlbbld avatar Mar 01 '22 10:03 dlbbld