hw-probe icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
hw-probe copied to clipboard

feature request: average temperature / fanspeed should also be a part of the test somehow

Open andrewfenn opened this issue 4 years ago • 6 comments

This is specifically about notebooks and having a good repository of knowledge on seeing how well temperature and fanspeed is being handled for different devices. What distro is handling it better, etc. I understand it wouldn't be exact data but having a large data volume set of temperatures along with fan speed configurations would be helpful to identifying issues of devices not being handled properly.

andrewfenn avatar Jul 22 '21 07:07 andrewfenn

How about lm_sensors?

https://linux-hardware.org/?probe=3600f5a7a8&log=sensors

linuxhw avatar Aug 06 '21 19:08 linuxhw

This looks great. Then I guess what I am requesting since that information is already available is for there to be some trend on the website to be able to see differences in temperatures for the same hardware between different upgrades / distros. Do you think it would be possible / helpful to do?

andrewfenn avatar Aug 09 '21 11:08 andrewfenn

Need to think. But usually people don't create more than one or max two probes of the same hardware on average. Comparing different instances of the same hardware is not correct too due to different operating conditions.

Also the temperature of my personal laptop linearly depends on the temperature outside the window.

linuxhw avatar Aug 10 '21 18:08 linuxhw

Yes, I think it's not going to be super accurate. I too have been thinking about how to handle this. I was thinking more along the lines of how well controlled fan-speeds are across different setups to be able to highlight what is best controlling notebooks if that makes more sense.

andrewfenn avatar Aug 11 '21 04:08 andrewfenn

Please share your thoughts on possible metrics to implement. One of the metrics may be minimal/average/maximal temperature per model to find out coolest/hottest models on the market.

linuxhw avatar Aug 11 '21 18:08 linuxhw

The repository with all lm_sensors reports has been created: https://github.com/linuxhw/Sensors

But analysis report (see README.md) is not ready yet - just showing minimal reached temp per model.

linuxhw avatar Oct 30 '21 14:10 linuxhw