EEGEdu
EEGEdu copied to clipboard
kylemath
Intro Section Problem
Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe. I have one comment regarding the intro section: you introduce electrical dipoles as potential differences along the neuron from soma to end of axon. I guess this is a bit misleading. I learned it is about differences between the dendritic tree and the cell soma. While dendrites of cortical pyramidal cells are nicely aligned in parallel summing up to measurable potentials, axons can go to very different directions and particularly orthogonal to the cortical columns. Would you contradict or mind adapting your figure? But it could also be nice to ask my students to find the mistake Lächelndes Gesicht mit geöffnetem Mund thanks again for the nice tool - great job! Cheers, Ben
ahh, i read this more carefully and realized you mean the FIGURES are incorrect, that is a bigger issue I guess, as I am actually just recycling the figures used in the excellent eeg101 https://github.com/NeuroTechX/eeg-101, how would you suggest the figures be changed? move the negative to the cell bodies instead of the axon?
No, the whole concept is incorrect as are the example sketchy neurons. Axons (outgoing information) do not play a role at all. Pyramidal cells in cortex have a cell body (soma) in deeper layers and dendritic (!) trees in upper layers. Thus the potential difference making the dipole is between soma and dendrites (incoming information). In your figure it is different type of neurons with dendrites branching directly at the soma in all directions and therefore not allowing a directed potential gradient. I attached some pics from my lecture. Probably they make my point clearer. I don't have the exact references at hand but you will be easily able to google them.
~Ben
Kyle Mathewson [email protected] schrieb am Di., 22. Sept. 2020, 03:15:
ahh, i read this more carefully and realized you mean the FIGURES are incorrect, that is a bigger issue I guess, as I am actually just recycling the figures used in the excellent eeg101 https://github.com/NeuroTechX/eeg-101, how would you suggest the figures be changed? move the negative to the cell bodies instead of the axon?
— You are receiving this because you authored the thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/kylemath/EEGEdu/issues/155#issuecomment-696462091, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AOG3BR2X7ZAE7ZC4FVJUEWTSG73DZANCNFSM4RUS4MRA .
yes I agree and understand, but likely won't be able to fix those figures for a couple weeks
what I am asking is if you see part of the prose that is incorrect, and if so can you point out where, or is it just the figures,
On the intro page it seems largely ok. only on module 4 (raw and filtered data) you refer to something done only in a later module:
Raw Data:
Last module we recorded the frequency bands while people had their eyes open or closed for 10 seconds. Although we predicted there should be larger alpha power when the eyes are closed, are results showed the opposite effect:
The rest i did not check in detail yet but will let you know when I stumble about sth.
Best, Ben
On Tue, Sep 22, 2020 at 8:48 AM Kyle Mathewson [email protected] wrote:
yes I agree and understand, but likely won't be able to fix those figures for a couple weeks
what I am asking is if you see part of the prose that is incorrect, and if so can you point out where, or is it just the figures,
— You are receiving this because you authored the thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/kylemath/EEGEdu/issues/155#issuecomment-696540663, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AOG3BR7BKAZ3QIZ34ZWQPK3SHBCE7ANCNFSM4RUS4MRA .