Sync dependencies between build.gradle and JBang script

[linux-china]

trafficstars

In edit mode, some developers add dependencies in build.gradle for code completion etc. Finally they should copy dependencies to JBang script with //DEPS directive. Introduce a shortcut to sync dependencies from Gradle to JBang script with //DEPS filled.

Reverse flow should be considered too. Introduce intention action for //DEPS and add dependency to build.gradle. With Github Copilot, and it's easy to add dependency in script.

[maxandersen]

this is not something that should be done by jbang idea plugin imo - at least not in its final form. users should not be encouraged to edit build.gradle when using jbang - build.gradle is to be treated as purely temporary intermediate format as jbang edit will regenerate build.gradle anyway.

we have prs/issues that suggest to add deps.txt as a more centralized location if that is a problem.

[linux-china]

@maxandersen I have implemented this feature in 0.3.0 version. Sync Dependencies Action: right click script file and sync dependencies between JBang and Gradle. //DEPS to implementation or implementation to //DEPS .

[maxandersen]

I really don't think this is right. Sure it's a nice feature but we should NOT assume build.gradle even exist.

[linux-china]

If build.gradle not found, and Sync JBang DEPS will not available.

For most developers, two ways to open JBang with IDEA:

• idea -e Hello.java: Light mode, and JBang plugin will not be loaded by IDEA
• jbang edit --open=idea HelloWorld.java : build.gradle available for plugin
• idea .: open current directory as idea project

I think we should have a good practice to code JBang script with IDEA, and developers can enjoy features supplied by the plugin.

[linux-china]

Sync DEPS as IDEA module's libraries when using idea . to open JBang project without build.gradle

The new logic as following:

• if build.gradle detected, sync DEPS between JBang and Gradle
• if build.gradle not detected, sync DEPS as IDEA module's libraries

[maxandersen]

I'm concerned whatever this sync does it gets out of sync (no pun intended :) with how jbang edit works; especially upcoming jbang edit . (see https://github.com/jbangdev/jbang/pull/1042).

p.s. could we move to use pull-request before pushing to main - would be great to learn a bit more on how idea plugins evolves and pull-requests lets one see that vs raw push to main - even if pushed more or less directly.

[linux-china]

Gradle project models for dependencies sync :

• JBang script as standalone module: good for mutli-module project

settings.gradle

include 'app'
include 'jbang1'

• JBang script as sourceset: single-module project

sourceSets {
  hello {
    java {
      srcDirs = ["src/hello/java"]
    }
  }

[maxandersen]

I really do not think the same action should be used to sync from build.gralde to java file and the java file to idea library. It's not symmetrical actions.

[linux-china]

I agree, too complicated for developers. What's your suggestion? just to keep DEPS to idea module in IDE?

If developers want to generate build.gradle, and it's easy with following command.

jbang edit --open=[editor] helloworld.java

I think build.gradle to DEPS not necessary, and I can remove these code.

[maxandersen]

the feature is interesting (similar could be done for maven) but should be in separate actions. so if interested in tuning that keep it in a separate action "Sync JBang with Gradle" or similar.

Also perfectly fine dropping it for now as we have no tests and there are so many edge cases I fear its going to be a nightmare to maintain.