slack icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
slack copied to clipboard

add an option to show full commit message instead of short title

Open openaphid opened this issue 7 years ago • 34 comments

https://github.com/integrations/slack/blob/master/lib/messages/push.js#L18

Is it possible to show full commit msg by adding a slack cmd? It would be more convenient for my team which enforces detailed commit log.

openaphid avatar Mar 01 '18 06:03 openaphid

What do you mean by: "by adding a slack cmd"?

  1. add a possibility to configure an option (by a command or whatever) that would show full commit message
  2. show full commit message only after typing another command

I hope you mean 1 - which I'm also for.

tomaszwro avatar Mar 01 '18 11:03 tomaszwro

The first one:)

openaphid avatar Mar 02 '18 02:03 openaphid

Is this still relevant? If so, just comment with any updates and we'll leave it open. Otherwise, if there is no further activity, it will be closed.

stale[bot] avatar May 01 '18 13:05 stale[bot]

Definitely relevant.

Why wontfix label added?

tomaszwro avatar May 02 '18 12:05 tomaszwro

Is this still relevant? If so, just comment with any updates and we'll leave it open. Otherwise, if there is no further activity, it will be closed.

stale[bot] avatar Jul 01 '18 12:07 stale[bot]

Just added slack integration and would love to have the option to see full commit messages, not just the title/subject when using /github subscript owner/repo commits.

unforswearing avatar Aug 09 '19 17:08 unforswearing

Thanks for bringing this topic back to our attention.

I am re-opening it, but I can't give any details if and when we are going to take a look at this.

🔈Everybody who thinks this is important or valuable to him or her, please upvote the OP, so that we can get an indicator about the existing demand. 🔈 Thanks 🙇

dennissivia avatar Aug 12 '19 13:08 dennissivia

This would improve communication within our team. We are encouraged to use a short title and detailed body, rather than a long title, but Slack only shows the title.

preciselytom avatar Feb 17 '20 09:02 preciselytom

It would be great to be able to show the full description in Slack. In the specific case that I'm interested in, it will allow people without a github access to read "more than one line information" in a slack channel. (if they had access, it would be to fight lazyness to click on the commit link) Thanks

basileFourcade avatar Mar 29 '20 17:03 basileFourcade

very needed feature, please reconsider its priority. I'd even say it should be the default behavior

Zoinen avatar Apr 10 '20 22:04 Zoinen

would be awesome to have this feature really needed

runik avatar Apr 10 '20 22:04 runik

we'd love to have this as an option as well. bitbucket behaved this way and now many of our descriptions are getting cut off

jlichti avatar May 19 '20 20:05 jlichti

This feature is really needed within our team

juliandreas avatar Aug 13 '20 14:08 juliandreas

+1

joeydong avatar Aug 14 '20 16:08 joeydong

We are still rating. Please consider implementing this feature.

stephenasamoah avatar Aug 27 '20 23:08 stephenasamoah

Any updates on this? It would be very useful for our team as well.

hdavis91 avatar Sep 08 '21 14:09 hdavis91

Adding a comment to chime in -- seeing the full description with a commit would be very helpful for our team as well!

natebluewizard avatar Sep 08 '21 23:09 natebluewizard

This would be a great feature for our team.

james-koehne avatar Sep 09 '21 00:09 james-koehne

Another voice behind this option - had to remove it almost as soon as we installed it ;-( Sadge.

bluewizardsupport avatar Sep 09 '21 00:09 bluewizardsupport

Seeing the full description of a commit is 'Essential' - with a capital 'E' - much love for the developer, but please can we have this feature - thanks in advance! :)

AndyWiltshireNZ avatar Sep 09 '21 00:09 AndyWiltshireNZ

This would be really useful for our team as well :)

jchapron avatar Oct 28 '21 16:10 jchapron

This would really be nice!

ludionisio avatar Oct 28 '21 17:10 ludionisio

What status on this, the commit-integration is kinda pointless if i still have to open github and read the body of the commit.

hugoup avatar Dec 14 '21 10:12 hugoup

Adding this functionality as a configurable option would really help encourage developers to write longform descriptive commit messages, and would make the notifications feel like a substantive communication and less like spam, at least in my org.

dariusk avatar Feb 08 '22 19:02 dariusk

would also love this

cloutsocks avatar Feb 28 '22 23:02 cloutsocks

Another vote, fixing this would improve communication a lot.

beddari avatar Mar 08 '22 10:03 beddari

Voting this. Cant believe this hasnt been done based on all the requests and how easy this is to implement via slack dev toolkit / webhook

nigel-loops avatar Mar 17 '22 10:03 nigel-loops

4 years passed.. please listen our voices

khcpietro avatar Jul 15 '22 00:07 khcpietro

Pretty disappointed that this is not implemented. It is very inconvenient.

KuzubValentin avatar Aug 24 '22 20:08 KuzubValentin

requesting this feature!

jon-minepi avatar Nov 24 '22 02:11 jon-minepi