Maui

Maui copied to clipboard

It seems that with the latest nightly (and maybe even stable now?) there are sometimes issues with a duplicate file name for the fullscreen icon file that is used in MediaElement.

We need to investigate how this happens and how to get rid of it!

---

[...] I am getting this error: Error: One or more duplicate file names were detected. All image output filenames must be unique: fullscreen (/{path}/.nuget/packages/communitytoolkit.maui.mediaelement/99.0.0-build-1813.105074/buildTransitive/Images/fullscreen.svg), fullscreen (/{path}/.nuget/packages/communitytoolkit.maui.mediaelement/99.0.0-build-1813.105074/buildTransitive/Images/fullscreen.svg)

Any ideas?

Originally posted by @briankanelson in https://github.com/CommunityToolkit/Maui/issues/1110#issuecomment-2074953533

Can you provide more info? I created a sample project and tried both media element from latest source (99.0.0-preview1839) and from current release 3.1.1. I had zero issues. Is there a specific setting I need to set in csproj file? I am trying with <MauiVersion>8.0.21</MauiVersion> I tried <MauiVersion>8.0.14</MauiVersion> with the same result.

BTW #1813 was merged last week and is/was a PR that fixes ios crash issues and if you want to test the pr where the file was added you can test #1692 which added full screen support. Testing again earlier versions might be useful as you should get zero reference to file at all. It did not exist then.

Can you provide more info? I created a sample project and tried both media element from latest source (99.0.0-preview1839) and from current release 3.1.1. I had zero issues. Is there a specific setting I need to set in csproj file? I am trying with <MauiVersion>8.0.21</MauiVersion> I tried <MauiVersion>8.0.14</MauiVersion> with the same result.

BTW #1813 was merged last week and is/was a PR that fixes ios crash issues and if you want to test the pr where the file was added you can test #1692 which added full screen support. Testing again earlier versions might be useful as you should get zero reference to file at all. It did not exist then.

@ne0rrmatrix could you please take a look to this comment, i described how you can reproduce it. Thanks. https://github.com/CommunityToolkit/Maui/issues/1110#issuecomment-2094217710

Can you provide more info? I created a sample project and tried both media element from latest source (99.0.0-preview1839) and from current release 3.1.1. I had zero issues. Is there a specific setting I need to set in csproj file? I am trying with <MauiVersion>8.0.21</MauiVersion> I tried <MauiVersion>8.0.14</MauiVersion> with the same result. BTW #1813 was merged last week and is/was a PR that fixes ios crash issues and if you want to test the pr where the file was added you can test #1692 which added full screen support. Testing again earlier versions might be useful as you should get zero reference to file at all. It did not exist then.

@ne0rrmatrix could you please take a look to this comment, i described how you can reproduce it. Thanks. #1110 (comment)

I cannot replicate the issue without a sample. I have tried both the sample app from repo and I created my own. I have had zero success at creating the bug. Please provide or attach a sample that clearly demonstrates the issue.

Can you provide more info? I created a sample project and tried both media element from latest source (99.0.0-preview1839) and from current release 3.1.1. I had zero issues. Is there a specific setting I need to set in csproj file? I am trying with <MauiVersion>8.0.21</MauiVersion> I tried <MauiVersion>8.0.14</MauiVersion> with the same result. BTW #1813 was merged last week and is/was a PR that fixes ios crash issues and if you want to test the pr where the file was added you can test #1692 which added full screen support. Testing again earlier versions might be useful as you should get zero reference to file at all. It did not exist then.

@ne0rrmatrix could you please take a look to this comment, i described how you can reproduce it. Thanks. #1110 (comment)

I cannot replicate the issue without a sample. I have tried both the sample app from repo and I created my own. I have had zero success at creating the bug. Please provide or attach a sample that clearly demonstrates the issue.

See attahcments.

Open Solution -> Run for iOS Debug - Any CPU | iPhone Simulator

Output 1>Microsoft.Maui.Resizetizer.After.targets(623,9): Error : One or more duplicate file names were detected. All image output filenames must be unique: fullscreen (/Users/.../.nuget/packages/communitytoolkit.maui.mediaelement/3.1.1/buildTransitive/Images/fullscreen.svg)

CommunityToolkitPckgTest.zip

I looked at the provided sample. Can verify that when you add a class library to an existing project where both have media element in both projects you will get an error about duplicate file names. I will investigate the issue.

possibly related issue found here: https://github.com/dotnet/maui/issues/19840 Will investigate further and see if they are related.

Hi @ne0rrmatrix! any possible date to release this change? Thanks!

hello! any news here? Thanks!

@luisabreu84 I am waiting on review and it looks good to go. Just need approval and then a maintainer with write privileges needs to push the changes.

I've approved with one minor comment 👍