Doesn't automatically restart

[wwwbfjxisiuz]

Geode Issue

• [X] I confirm that this bug is NOT related to a mod but directly to Geode Loader itself.

Platform

Windows

SDK commit

No response

Geode Version

v2.0.0-beta.23

Mods Installed

geode.backup v1.0.5 geode.betterpause v1.6.8 geode.coinsinpausemenu v1.1.2 geode.customkeybinds v1.5.2 geode.entersearch v1.6.9 geode.hidepausebutton v1.2.0 geode.levelthumnails v1.0.3 geode.nodeids v1.8.1 geode.wavetrailglowy v1.0.0 geode.megahackpro v8.0.0

Expected Behavior

Whenever I update or install new mods, I want it to restart and automatically back to the game.

Actual Behavior

After clicking those, I have to open the game manually.

Steps to Reproduce

By clicking the pink restart button.

Additional Information

I have deleted and reinstalled the whole GD & Geode files once before, but it kept happening.

[RayDeeUx]

i have 240 mods installed (220+ active) and get this once in a while. from personal experience i would recommend having a few apps open possible to avoid running into this issue.

also, you seem to have edited the mod IDs.

[wwwbfjxisiuz]

Thanks, and my edition is adding Mega Hack Pro mod, since I downloaded it back after posting the original report, and I think it's necessary to edit it.

[xparadoxical]

I can repro this most of the time when restarting using khronophobia.shortcuts_menu. The log window stays visible for several seconds after the game window was closed. Maybe it's something to do with saving? Also I don't remember this happening a few months ago, restarting didn't use to be an issue.

[RayDeeUx]

@xparadoxical let me explain why this is difficult to reproduce:

I can repro this most of the time when restarting using khronophobia.shortcuts_menu

This is the relevant line of code responsible for restarting the game from khronophobia.shortcuts_menu: https://github.com/Khronophobia/Shortcuts-Menu/blob/main/src/ShortcutsPopup.cpp#L552

You can also see this same line of code in these two repositories: https://github.com/Weebifying/restartbutton-geode/blob/main/src/main.cpp#L15 https://github.com/geode-sdk/geode/blob/main/loader/src/ui/internal/list/ModListCell.cpp#L262

All three of these lines of code call the same function from within Geode itself. khronophobia.shortcuts_menu by itself isn't causing the issue, and more importantly, @wwwbfjxisiuz's mod list doesn't include any mention of shortcuts_menu (edited mod IDs or otherwise).

Also I don't remember this happening a few months ago, restarting didn't use to be an issue.

Given the three links I just shared, the issue clearly originates from some change within Geode's restart code itself (and not from khronophobia.shortcuts_menu or any specific mod); I could hypothetically publish an entirely new mod that also calls Geode's utils::game::restart(); function and run into this issue sooner or later.

[xparadoxical]

I didn't say it's caused by the mod I mentioned, just wanted to share a quicker way to restart than installing/updating/removing a mod

[matcool]

stale, reopen if needed

[xparadoxical]

this stopped happening at some point and never happened to me again, probably it's fixed

[wwwbfjxisiuz]

this stopped happening at some point and never happened to me again, probably it's fixed

You're right. I hope this problem is done and will be gone forever.