Craig Stuart Sapp
Craig Stuart Sapp
> It wood be good to have also the values "hauptstimme" and "nebenstimme" and/or the generic term "analytical" available. Those are also the names of the brackets in English, by...
`P0` should be `P1` for a perfect unison (no zeros in musical mathematics, since it was not widely accepted until the 16th/17th centuries). (Perfect fifth is `P5`, where `P0` is...
> what would you suggest we call them? Good luck on that 😉 > I'm a little unsure about the value "steppedMelodicContour". Can we replace it with "numericMelodicContour"? I think...
> Still, I'd be ok with using "intervals" instead of "mint". I think this pairs well with "semitones". That sound good to me. "humdrumMint" is over-specific, because the "mint" description...
> but can't support sd or su since it's ambiguous -- is `sus` "same-up-same", or "same or higher-same"? I don't think parsons supports spaces between tokens? * `s` = same...
> Also not sure if we want to allow intervals specified with no direction or amount, which `@intm` allows. "M2" -- up or down? `+M`? You should always want to...
> https://music-encoding.org/guidelines/v5/data-types/data.INTERVAL.MELODIC.html A ha. That is a mixture of "parsons" (extended), "intervals" and "semitones" interval types: ```xml u|d|s|n|sd|su (\+|\-)?([AdMmP])?[0-9]+ (\+|\-)?\d+(\.\d+)?hs ``` The pattern `u|d|s|n|sd|su` is Parson's code but adding `n`,...
> I would also suggest that we remove the trailing 'hs' from the pattern `(\+|\-)?\d+(\.\d+)?hs`, at least in the incipit context. I was also thinking about that, but the problem...
> Couldn't we add `8` and/or`8va` (and` 8vb`, `15ma`, `15mb`, etc) to `data.LINESTARTENDSYMBOL`? There is a complication of these two symbols: The second one as a text could be `8_va`....
> There's a Verovio option already: --octave-alternative-symbols You could have mentioned that in the first place 😜 I reviewed all of the verovio 5.1 options a few days ago: https://github.com/humdrum-tools/humdrum-notation-plugin/blob/master/_includes/verovio-options-3.15.json...