docs icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
docs copied to clipboard

Update DB Schema in Combination with Blue-Green Deployment

Open nocin opened this issue 1 year ago • 2 comments

Hi,

via https://github.com/cap-js/docs/issues/427 I found the new content related to DB schema updates. In this section are two new topics for me. First, that you can update the DB schema using cds-mtx update, and second, that you can combine this with Blue-Green Deployment. I have two question on that.

I would like to setup up Blue-Green Deployment for our Multitenant application, but we are not using a sidecar, means we are not using cds-mtx.

The command must be run in the MTX application / sidecar root directory with the application environment.

Does cds-mtx update work, when not having a sidecar?

And is there any more content related to CAP and Blue-Green Deployment? The only post I found in this community is this one, which raises the question, what happens if a DB model upgrade fails? Is there any rollback? From my understanding this is not possible, because the previous live version is deleted, when setting the idle version productive.

It would really help, if the CAP docs can be enhanced on this topic.

Thanks! Nico

nocin avatar May 27 '24 09:05 nocin

Hi @nocin ,

Thanks for raising this question. I'll get back to you soon after reCAP.

renejeglinsky avatar May 27 '24 14:05 renejeglinsky

Hi @nocin , I'm picking this up now and let you know about the progress. Thanks, René

renejeglinsky avatar Jun 12 '24 13:06 renejeglinsky

Hi,

cds-mtx is part of @sap/cds-mtxs and can therefore only be used with the MTX sidecar.

CAP doesn't give any advice or best practices wrt. blue-green deployment as of now, but it might change once it's decided in our roadmap that it'll get a stronger focus.

Best regards, Steffen

swaldmann avatar Oct 16 '24 12:10 swaldmann

Hi @nocin , for now I can't close this request with a success message. But, please watch out in the release notes where we will mention if the documentation around this topic has been enhanced.

All the best, René

renejeglinsky avatar Oct 29 '24 14:10 renejeglinsky