brave-browser icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
brave-browser copied to clipboard

[Android] setting to put URL bar, shields, overflow menu, etc on bottom of screen

Open LaurenWags opened this issue 7 years ago • 44 comments
trafficstars

Brave Software staff comment (by @bsclifton)

This is possible already if you visit brave://flags and search for android-bottom-toolbar flag and enable.

We'll be rolling this out when the time is right - stay tuned to this issue for more information 😄


Did you search for similar issues before submitting this one? Yes

Description: Chromium 66 removed the 'Chrome Home' flag from chrome://flags which gave the user the ability to put URL bar, etc on the bottom of the screen. This was a popular feature and it would be good to get it back if we can.

Requested via community: https://community.brave.com/t/reimplement-bottom-screen-navigation/21529

Device Details:

  • Install Type(ARM, x86): all
  • Device(Phone, Tablet, Phablet): all
  • Android Version: all

Brave Version: 1.0.45+ (chromium 66 was introduced with 1.0.45)

Steps to reproduce: 1. Update to or install 1.0.45 or higher version. 2. Navigate to chrome://flags 3. Chrome Home option is no longer available.

Actual Behavior Chromium 66 removed this option.

Expected Behavior Would be good if we could have a Brave setting for this as it was a popular feature.

Is this an issue with Beta build? n/a

Is this an issue in the currently released version? yes

Additional information This feature was purposefully dropped in chromium 66 - https://www.androidpolice.com/2018/02/16/experimental-chrome-home-interface-now-chrome-duplex-address-bar-back-top/

LaurenWags avatar May 03 '18 16:05 LaurenWags

+1. Please bring this feature back.

whour avatar May 03 '18 17:05 whour

+1 from Twitter https://twitter.com/nonameguy321/status/992836380001644544

eljuno avatar May 05 '18 18:05 eljuno

+1s from Twitter https://twitter.com/JaimePG/status/994678885903192064 https://twitter.com/BlnaryMlke/status/994667067965091840 and https://twitter.com/nyquildotorg/status/994669678655033344

eljuno avatar May 10 '18 21:05 eljuno

+1... This was the main reason I used brave (although it would be even better with more than 8 bookmarks underneath the bar)

niekverw avatar May 10 '18 22:05 niekverw

This would be great! I've currently disabled updates for brave so that I can stick to the version that still has the address bar at the bottom.

nejsimon avatar May 11 '18 16:05 nejsimon

+1 from community https://community.brave.com/t/adressline-bottom/21934?u=eljuno

eljuno avatar May 12 '18 18:05 eljuno

+1 from community https://community.brave.com/t/adressline-bottom/21934?u=eljuno

eljuno avatar May 12 '18 18:05 eljuno

+1 Screens can get large and keyboards are typically at the bottom of the screen already. This feature was a no-brainer to have.

Sidenote, I wish Google or the Brave team would implement a new tab feature like IOS Chrome used to have.

Laynezilla avatar May 15 '18 04:05 Laynezilla

+1 from Twitter user @JeffScript.

image

jonathansampson avatar May 15 '18 23:05 jonathansampson

Guys , please , OPTIONAL please ! I'd prefer 'url bar on top' ... May be just one about:flags switch!

D0ve avatar May 22 '18 08:05 D0ve

But, if so much discussion goes on, I'd suggest some more...

In settings must be 'UI Settings' section. I. There must be 'URL bar' settings, determins:

  1. 'Top' or 'Botton'
  2. 'Mobile' or 'Tablet' elements layout 2a. Enable or Disable 'Tabs Previews Button' (from 'Mobile' layout) if 'Tablet' layout is set on.

II.And there must be 'Show Tabs' settings, determins: /yes, tabs, which we can see on tablets and on desktops either/

  1. 'On' or 'Off' Show Tabs
  2. 'Top' or 'Bottom' Shown Tabs

So, these are maximum from hardcoded ui elements thats already exist in Brave code. No need to create new elements. But would be great if those elements be switched by parts!!!/independently smartphone or tablet it is/... ... And also TOP or BOTTOM!

D0ve avatar May 22 '18 09:05 D0ve

+1 this in an essential feature for wide screen phone like 18:9

Nikoleos avatar Jul 30 '18 22:07 Nikoleos

+1

unfamiliarplace avatar Aug 13 '18 23:08 unfamiliarplace

FYI google is now testing a new UI where you'd have a button on an an extra toolbar at the bottom of the screen that focuses the URL bar. Not a great solution IMO because now you have two toolbars cluttering the screen but at least it makes large phones more manageable.

screenshot_20180815-072631

nejsimon avatar Aug 15 '18 05:08 nejsimon

+1 from Community: https://www.reddit.com/r/brave_browser/comments/9vlno9/chrome_duet_setting_does_not_stick_in_brave/

Brave-Matt avatar Nov 09 '18 21:11 Brave-Matt

Thanks for pointing me to this GitHub page from Reddit, just to be clear this feature is already possible in the current version of Brave and can be enabled by setting the "Chrome Duet" flag to Disabled. Once you relaunch the browser, the menu bar will shift down to the bottom for a while but go back to the top again after a couple of browsing sessions for some reason.

phrozact avatar Nov 09 '18 23:11 phrozact

+1 from Community https://community.brave.com/t/how-can-i-set-the-buttons-from-top-to-bottom-of-the-android-app/41026?u=eljuno

eljuno avatar Dec 26 '18 22:12 eljuno

I have a bug that makes my control bar appear at the bottom, without an option to adjust it. It seems similar to this feature request... Please fix.

MrTechLust avatar Mar 16 '19 04:03 MrTechLust

Please make this new bottom bar optional. While I know many people have asked for it, many others do not like it (including myself). The best solution here is to make it a toggle so that those that want it can have it and those who don't aren't forced to have it.

bjg222 avatar Mar 17 '19 18:03 bjg222

Please make the address bar and shield at the bottom as the home and tab and + are already there in order to have only one bar and not two like kiwi browser

Nikoleos avatar Mar 19 '19 20:03 Nikoleos

+1 Kiwi Browser have this feature too.

r-chvrt avatar Nov 22 '19 10:11 r-chvrt

Ref: https://github.com/brave/brave-browser/issues/6405

szaimen avatar Nov 22 '19 11:11 szaimen

Recently got a Fold, and the disconnect between candybar and tablet mode tab management is huge. The desktop-esque interface seems to lack any concept of tab groups and is stuck to the top of the screen. Vivaldi seems to be able to use "normal"/candybar mode style cards and tab groups in tablet mode as well as candybar mode.

Coffeeling avatar Aug 09 '23 00:08 Coffeeling

+1 from @atefBB via https://github.com/brave/brave-browser/issues/39023 +1 from @kristoffk15 via https://github.com/brave/brave-browser/issues/38015 +1 from many others at https://github.com/brave/brave-browser/issues/34524 +1 from @txtyash via https://github.com/brave/brave-browser/issues/20923 +1 from @Varniit-pro-90s via https://github.com/brave/brave-browser/issues/35443

cc: @timchilds

Removed priority label so we can re-assess in our next triage meeting

bsclifton avatar Jul 09 '24 23:07 bsclifton

Updating project board status to match what https://github.com/brave/brave-browser/issues/35443 was set as

bsclifton avatar Jul 09 '24 23:07 bsclifton

Please don't forget the tablet mode UI if you're doing a redesign. Tabs, tab groups and addresses at the bottom would be amazing for foldable users.

Coffeeling avatar Jul 09 '24 23:07 Coffeeling

+1 to moving the address bar to the bottom on android. coming from ios, im surprised to see that android doesnt have the same feature

moonxkang avatar Aug 16 '24 21:08 moonxkang

+1 to moving the address bar to the bottom on android. coming from ios, im surprised to see that android doesnt have the same feature

Or editable button for navigation buttons. It is all like chrome but with crypto and adblocking. I dont see brave improving UI of the app for users coming or leaving chrome for reasons.

ghost avatar Aug 28 '24 00:08 ghost

I seen some closed posts that redirects to this one. And this one was created by 2018. September 2024, 6 years later, the feature is still requested (I found many Reddit posts about it) and still not implemented.

Mozilla is back on track in an active development of Firefox. I came back to it some weeks ago and made it my default browser ! Just love to have its address bar at bottom on Android.

Dominic-t3ch avatar Sep 28 '24 03:09 Dominic-t3ch

+1 to this feature, this is just expected of any mobile device UI.

g-libardi avatar Oct 28 '24 06:10 g-libardi