github-for-mac-issues icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
github-for-mac-issues copied to clipboard

"git commit --amend" feature in github for mac

Open zrrtcs opened this issue 13 years ago • 36 comments
trafficstars

some of us who sometimes carelessly done commit need this. thanks.

ps: please do not leave a comment in this issue thread here only for "+1"

zrrtcs avatar Nov 17 '12 02:11 zrrtcs

+1

paulocheque avatar Apr 27 '13 22:04 paulocheque

+1

thomasmery avatar May 09 '13 06:05 thomasmery

Absolutely need that O.O! +2

IngwiePhoenix avatar May 30 '13 19:05 IngwiePhoenix

:+1:

stickel avatar Aug 21 '13 18:08 stickel

+1

mrmurphy avatar Oct 10 '13 17:10 mrmurphy

+1

borisdivjak avatar Nov 01 '13 02:11 borisdivjak

+1

jiserra avatar Feb 16 '14 20:02 jiserra

+1

wowthatisrandom avatar Mar 16 '14 19:03 wowthatisrandom

+1

josh18 avatar Apr 03 '14 02:04 josh18

+1

olutsenko avatar Apr 15 '14 10:04 olutsenko

Can't the same effect be accomplished via the "Edit" button on the last "unsynced commit"?

screen shot 2014-05-08 at 7 03 04 pm

nfarina avatar May 09 '14 02:05 nfarina

Can't the same effect be accomplished via the "Edit" button on the last "unsynced commit"?

Yes, but doesn't help if you have sync'd all your commits. The added steps of having to hit the 'edit' button, make sure the new changes you want aren't overridden, then running commit again are more tedious than, say, a checkbox option to commit --amend

stickel avatar May 11 '14 00:05 stickel

Am 11.05.2014 um 02:27 schrieb Stickel [email protected]:

Can't the same effect be accomplished via the "Edit" button on the last "unsynced commit"?

Yes, but doesn't help if you have sync'd all your commits. The added steps of having to hit the 'edit' button, make sure the new changes you want aren't overridden, then running commit again are more tedious than, say, a checkbox option to commit —amend

Not to mention that it also looks cleaner in your commit history.

IngwiePhoenix avatar May 11 '14 00:05 IngwiePhoenix

Can't the same effect be accomplished via the "Edit" button on the last "unsynced commit"?

Yes, but doesn't help if you have sync'd all your commits.

Well this is kind of a different feature request - modifying a commit post-sync would require a force push, which has new implications.

nfarina avatar May 19 '14 23:05 nfarina

+1

MartinMekk avatar Sep 24 '14 09:09 MartinMekk

+1

knightq avatar Sep 24 '14 12:09 knightq

+1

elving avatar Apr 08 '15 14:04 elving

+100

arena avatar May 20 '15 23:05 arena

In the meantime, if autocorrect changes the word "svg" to "sag" and makes you sound weird. You can go to the terminal and use these fun commands like I just did (proceed with caution): git commit --amend -m "New commit message" git push -f

arena avatar May 20 '15 23:05 arena

+1

asm avatar Oct 13 '16 17:10 asm

+1

adamwoodnz avatar Dec 07 '16 20:12 adamwoodnz

+1

0x0584 avatar Jan 23 '17 20:01 0x0584

+1

mspangdal avatar Feb 15 '17 08:02 mspangdal

  • 1 TRILLION

v1co0 avatar Apr 06 '17 18:04 v1co0

  • 1

DamZera avatar Jun 02 '17 09:06 DamZera

+1

pbrueske avatar Aug 02 '17 09:08 pbrueske

+1

chriswalz avatar Aug 07 '17 01:08 chriswalz

👍

KayoticSully avatar Oct 27 '17 13:10 KayoticSully

+1

Why isn't this implemented yet?

EDIT: I guess it's because of the undo commit feature which works kinda the same, though amending doesn't require reselecting lines/chunks.

stianhoiland avatar Nov 01 '17 14:11 stianhoiland

+1

javiergranados avatar Nov 12 '17 09:11 javiergranados