asdf icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
asdf copied to clipboard

FITS to ASDF conversion tool?

Open drdavella opened this issue 8 years ago • 2 comments

Inspired in part by this awesome article from an interesting blog:

The only strategy in getting people to switch to your product is to eliminate barriers. Imagine that it’s 1991. The dominant spreadsheet, with 100% market share, is Lotus 123. You’re the product manager for Microsoft Excel. Ask yourself: what are the barriers to switching? What keeps users from becoming Excel customers tomorrow?

s/spreadsheet/astronomical data format/ and s/Lotus 123/FITS/ and s/Microsoft Excel/ASDF/ and maybe it makes sense.

drdavella avatar Jul 12 '17 22:07 drdavella

There is already, sort of, depending on how you look at things. There is support for putting FITS in ASDF with a view that round-tripping doesn't lose any FITS info (like header comments). But perhaps there should be a mode of making FITS more natural ASDF (and not round-trippable). The point about allowing backward conversion is quite valid. It can't easily be done in general, but something could be done for a subset of cases (or with explicit restrictions on what is supported). (Perhaps the infinitely nested FITS as the equivalent of nested YAML? Clumsy? Yes. Very Clumsy.)

perrygreenfield avatar Jul 13 '17 14:07 perrygreenfield

I just spent 10 mins combing the docs for this exact feature. I wanted a ASDF.from_fits class method to quickly get an ASDF object I can play with using an existing FITS image/table. Please make it happen.

pllim avatar Mar 12 '18 16:03 pllim