archinstall icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
archinstall copied to clipboard

Crash in attempting to do arch install with manual partitioning

Open henry7720 opened this issue 8 months ago • 5 comments

Which ISO version are you using?

2024-04-01

The installation log

https://0x0.st/8_-3.log

describe the problem

Description of the issue

I was installing on a ThinkPad T480.

Then I went through standard install steps, both with manual ext4 and btrfs file system setups. No matter what I try, it crashes!

henry7720 avatar Apr 05 '25 07:04 henry7720

So there's a couple of attempts in this log, and at least one of them is trying to re-use existing partitions, and also create new subvolumes at the same time. Causing it to crash because @home already exists. So new subvolumes should not be created when re-using partitions.

Torxed avatar Apr 05 '25 09:04 Torxed

Except I am not reusing partitions, I attempt to delete first and recreate and the same crash comes. In general, the crash appears.

henry7720 avatar Apr 05 '25 16:04 henry7720

I'm having the same issue on qemu

The March ISO hadn't this issue, if I remember correctly

BTW, manual partitioning related issues are recurrent bugs on Archinstall ,that appear time by time.

I think the team should consider to hardly revisit the way that archistall manage manual paritioning , and do more tests about before pushing updates

thealio avatar Apr 24 '25 20:04 thealio

i experienced the same issues, however i found a workaround

i used gparted to delete partitions (to wipe them), hoping that if the partitions were already made then the issue would go away if archinstall just created a new partition with free space, and it did

so it seems to be triggered by wiping an existing partition at least (don't know about deleting an existing one, can't remember if i tried that or not. i was frustrated (nvidia broke my system again)).

as long as your installing onto "free space" then it should be fine... hopefully

9thyear2 avatar Jun 23 '25 12:06 9thyear2

Maybe related: https://github.com/archlinux/archinstall/issues/3689

In the presence of an existing BTRFS (which must be kept as it is, and must not be mounted), there's no way to install...

Of course, this makes the installer completely unusable (I want to have several installations on my machines) and I agree with @thealio

I think the team should consider to hardly revisit the way that archistall manage manual paritioning , and do more tests about before pushing updates

LorenzoBettini avatar Jul 28 '25 20:07 LorenzoBettini