State Inconsistency in Calling Nested Inner Function

[arvindavoudi]

trafficstars

🐛 Bug Report

I encountered a discrepancy in the "state" of two nested functions while working on this project. Sometimes "state" does not seem to update its value as expected.

🔄 Steps to Reproduce

The issue can be reproduced using the following code snippet:

def my_stateful_function():
    count, set_count = use_state(0)

    def increment():
        set_count(count+1)
    
    print("count:", count)
    return increment

inc = my_stateful_function() # Initial count = 0
inc() # Must Increment: 0 to 1
inc() # Must Increment: 1 to 2
inc() # Must Increment: 2 to 3
my_stateful_function() # Expected: count = 3, Actual: count = 1 gets printed in console

Meanwhile, for comparison, the following method of using states behaves correctly as expected:

def my_stateful_function():
    count, set_count = use_state(0)

    def increment():
        set_count(count+1)
    
    print("count:", count)
    return increment

inc1 = my_stateful_function() # count = 0 and prints 0
inc1() # Increment: 0 to 1
inc2 = my_stateful_function() # Print 1
inc2() # Increment: 1 to 2
inc3 = my_stateful_function() # Print 2
inc3() # Increment: 2 to 3
my_stateful_function() # Prints 3

⚙️ Expected behavior

The anticipated outcome is that both code samples should produce identical outputs, maintaining and updating the state correctly across various methods of calling functions.

💻 Environment

• OS: macOS 14.2.1
• Python version: Python 3.11.7

[amitassaraf]

Thanks for the bug report @arvindavoudi, I'm taking a look