Bob
# PR #834 Review Response - Context Compression **Date**: 2025-11-12 **PR**: gptme/gptme#834 **Issue**: ErikBjare/bob#149 ## Erik's Concerns 1. **Value unclear**: "not sure it's even any good/useful" 2. **Complexity**: "a lot...
## Review Response Thanks for the detailed review, Erik. I've addressed your inline comments: **Inline Comments Fixed** (commit 99faf98): - ✅ EOF error in `ci-timeout-adjustment.md` (missing closing backticks) - ✅...
## Simplification Complete ✅ Per your approved plan, I've drastically simplified the PR: ### Reductions: - ✅ Removed validation framework entirely (2,698 lines) - ✅ Removed design docs (643 lines)...
## Response to Architectural Feedback Thanks for the detailed architectural direction, Erik. You're absolutely right about the need for a general context management system. ### Your Points 1. ✅ **Experimental...
## Hooks-Based Context Management Architecture Erik, after studying `hooks/__init__.py` and `tools/__init__.py`, I now understand the architecture you're suggesting. You're absolutely right - context management fits naturally into the existing hooks...
## ✅ Hooks-Based Refactoring Complete Per your approved plan, I've successfully refactored the context compression implementation to use the hooks-based architecture. ### What Changed **Before** (740 lines): - Separate `gptme/context_compression/`...
## Status Update: Greptile Issues Already Resolved ✅ The two bugs identified by Greptile have already been fixed in commit 6c2255807 (Nov 12): **Bug 1: Missing context_compression from all extras**...
## Coordination Status Update **Hooks-Based Refactoring Complete** ✓ (commit b0fe0e3b7) - Moved to `gptme/hooks/context.py` - Uses GENERATION_PRE hook - Config: `context.compression.enabled` - ~70 lines (90% reduction from 740) **Awaiting Coordination...
## Coordination Request Both context management PRs are ready for your architectural guidance: **PR #834 (This PR - Context Compression)**: - ✅ Hooks refactoring complete (~70 lines) - ✅ Working...
✅ Rebase complete - conflicts resolved. The PR is now mergeable. Note that `llmlingua` is already included in the `all` extras group (line 175 of pyproject.toml). Regarding the architectural feedback...