LSP Copilot chat, stops working

[DJManas]

Hello,

today I used LSP copilot for working and after some time, it stopped working. I use ctrl + shift + p, copilot chat, enter question and nothing generates.

In console I see:

Traceback (most recent call last):
  File "/home/djmanas/.config/sublime-text/Packages/LSP-copilot/plugin/commands.py", line 250, in <lambda>
    wcm.prompt(callback=lambda msg: self._on_prompt(plugin, session, msg), initial_text=message)
  File "/home/djmanas/.config/sublime-text/Packages/LSP-copilot/plugin/commands.py", line 335, in _on_prompt
    if not (request := prepare_conversation_turn_request(wcm.conversation_id, wcm.window.id(), msg, view, views)):
  File "/home/djmanas/.config/sublime-text/Packages/LSP-copilot/plugin/helpers.py", line 234, in prepare_conversation_turn_request
    if not (selection := view_.sel()[0]) or view_.substr(selection).isspace():
  File "/opt/sublime_text/Lib/python38/sublime.py", line 2291, in __getitem__
    raise IndexError()
IndexError

Sublime-Text: 4_4184 (Yes it dev so I dunno if it should not go to them) Gentoo Linux

Thanks, Regards, Petr Sourek

[TerminalFi]

TODO: Fix line https://github.com/TerminalFi/LSP-copilot/blob/a0c75e065e362bfbb000d9b4a2c68ceb31c94c8b/plugin/helpers.py#L234

[jfcherng]

TODO: Fix line

So there is either no cursor (which is supposed not to happen) or view_ is wrong 🤔

[DJManas]

If you can point me to what I should look for, I will be able to test it next time it happens.

EDIT: Or maybe I can take a look how to debug it, when it happens.

[jfcherng]

Reproduceable steps would help if it's possible.

[DJManas]

Reproduceable steps would help if it's possible.

I will try, but the problem is, that I had been developing python script since morning and suddenly when I got back with cup of coffee the Copilot was not responding and error was in console. We will see if it happens tonight or tomorrow during the day.

[jfcherng]

Reproduceable steps would help if it's possible.

I will try, but the problem is, that I had been developing python script since morning and suddenly when I got back with cup of coffee the Copilot was not responding and error was in console. We will see if it happens tonight or tomorrow during the day.

I see. Sometimes it's just hard to find a stable way to reproduce a bug.

[DJManas]

Reproduceable steps would help if it's possible.

I will try, but the problem is, that I had been developing python script since morning and suddenly when I got back with cup of coffee the Copilot was not responding and error was in console. We will see if it happens tonight or tomorrow during the day.

I see. Sometimes it's just hard to find a stable way to reproduce a bug.

It seems the problem occurs everytime I launch Copilot chat from debug. I launch my project (python), debugger is stopped at breakpoint and I press ctrl+shift+p and launch Copilot chat, the window for question opens, but when I write question and hit send to copilot it doesn't answer and error is in the console.

[TerminalFi]

@DJManas i am seeing this now as well. I hope to have time this weekend to review both our code and any changes that may have occurred in the upstream copilot.vim that we may have missed

[TerminalFi]

@jfcherng

Looks like something changed, and when creating a new conversation and sending an empty turn message. It doesn't like it. We should try and not send an empty message when creating a conversation now

[TerminalFi]

@jfcherng

Looks like something changed, and when creating a new conversation and sending an empty turn message. It doesn't like it. We should try and not send an empty message when creating a conversation now

Initial message here can be blank https://github.com/TerminalFi/LSP-copilot/blob/530359c6184592c77cb1f996a1b6eeb32430fa44/plugin/commands.py#L276

So maybe we need a way to send a message Hello if this is a brand new conversation? Or postpone this until user provides first message?

[jfcherng]

I am not sure what's happening since copilot chat seems to just work on my side.

[StephenPTxEng]

I am having the same issue. Used to work great until about November of '24. Then it started not responding to chat messages, but would respond to pre-defined commands (/fix, /explain). Now, it doesn't respond to anything. It opens the chat that has been running but doesn't post the new query. If i delete the running chat, nothing changes.

I removed the package, then re-added it. I then sent a "Hello" message, to which it responded. I then asked it a question about my code, but was already broken again.

I tried signing out then signing back in, but no change.

Is there a way to get error messages for you?

[StephenPTxEng]

right after i submitted that message, i tried again and it worked this time. I realized i was attempting to reference temporary code (not code saved in a file). Turns out that the plugin does not reference code from the editor; it references code from the file (which is open in the editor).

The plugin cannot reference unsaved code (code which only exists in the editor, but not in a file) Is this correct?

[jfcherng]

right after i submitted that message, i tried again and it worked this time. I realized i was attempting to reference temporary code (not code saved in a file). Turns out that the plugin does not reference code from the editor; it references code from the file (which is open in the editor).

The plugin cannot reference unsaved code (code which only exists in the editor, but not in a file) Is this correct?

On my side, if you select those codes, it works.

[StephenPTxEng]

strange. I highlight code, run the "Copilot: Chat" command, and the window remains blank. This problem only happens with code that is unsaved.

[DJManas]

The plugin cannot reference unsaved code (code which only exists in the editor, but not in a file) Is this correct?

I agree that this might be problem, but in my first post I didn't referenced anything, still learning how to use Copilot so most of my prompts are mostly questions, not referencing my code yet. But its good point.

[TerminalFi]

Just confirming I am able to reproduce this issue. I am looking into it.

[TerminalFi]

I've identified the issue. This line below fails if the view does not have a file on disk.

https://github.com/TerminalFi/LSP-copilot/blob/530359c6184592c77cb1f996a1b6eeb32430fa44/plugin/helpers.py#L199

I will try to find time today to fix this.

[StephenPTxEng]

today I used LSP copilot for working and after some time, it stopped working. I use ctrl + shift + p, copilot chat, enter question and nothing generates.

I misunderstood your original question then; sorry for hijacking the thread! I agree with @TerminalFi for the reason why. An invalid "hello" message could corrupt future questions for that session.

@DJManas are you able to find steps that let you use CoPilot again? (e.g. Close and Reopen Sublime | Sign Out -> Sign back in to CoPilot | Copilot: Destroy Conversation | Remove package then re-add package)? Or is it permanently broken right now?

[TerminalFi]

today I used LSP copilot for working and after some time, it stopped working. I use ctrl + shift + p, copilot chat, enter question and nothing generates.

I misunderstood your original question then; sorry for hijacking the thread! I agree with @TerminalFi for the reason why. An invalid "hello" message could corrupt future questions for that session.

@DJManas are you able to find steps that let you use CoPilot again? (e.g. Close and Reopen Sublime | Sign Out -> Sign back in to CoPilot | Copilot: Destroy Conversation | Remove package then re-add package)? Or is it permanently broken right now?

It will work on files that are actually saved to disk currently.

We think we also found a bug in LSP for unsaved views.

[DJManas]

today I used LSP copilot for working and after some time, it stopped working. I use ctrl + shift + p, copilot chat, enter question and nothing generates.

I misunderstood your original question then; sorry for hijacking the thread! I agree with @TerminalFi for the reason why. An invalid "hello" message could corrupt future questions for that session.

@DJManas are you able to find steps that let you use CoPilot again? (e.g. Close and Reopen Sublime | Sign Out -> Sign back in to CoPilot | Copilot: Destroy Conversation | Remove package then re-add package)? Or is it permanently broken right now?

Seems that copilot is working today, I will continue to use it. As stated in my first comment. I have problems, that it stops working after some time (not sure why), but before it its working normally (talking about chat).

And I had written, that I am not using it on unsaved files, but in the same sentence I had written, that its good point. Now thinking about it, and working, when I see there is problem (in source) I will save first and try again. I guess this is thing, that would not get into my mind, when I have problems in source code usage.

[jfcherng]

I've identified the issue. This line below fails if the view does not have a file on disk.

LSP-copilot/plugin/helpers.py

Line 199 in 530359c

if not view.file_name(): I will try to find time today to fix this.

I have fixed and pushed that line. But another issue related to LSP (wrong buffer ID in payloads) is still required to be addressed in order to this issue.