OrcaSlicer icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
OrcaSlicer copied to clipboard

"Fill bed with copies" does not perform well (enough)

Open foreachthing opened this issue 2 years ago • 7 comments

Describe the bug

Comparing to PrusaSlicer, OrcaSlicer does not perform very well in "filling bed" (I only wish those where instances over copies - but that's another (open) issue).

3mf File for This Bug

No need, STEP file is attached. USM-Headset.zip

To Reproduce

  1. load STEP
  2. check "arrange" settings to be: 3.5 mm distance, rotation enabled (<- this matters!).
  3. "Fill bed with copies"
  4. observe results
  5. repeat with PrusaSlicer (>= 2.6.0)

Expected behavior

Very similar results, if not the same.

Screenshots

OrcaSlicer

With rotation enabled: image

With rotation disabled 1: image

With rotation disabled 2: image

PrusaSlicer

image

Desktop

  • Windows 10/11
  • OrcaSlicer 1.6.4
  • PrusaSlicer 2.6.1rc1

foreachthing avatar Aug 24 '23 06:08 foreachthing

Not sure if it's caused by the "Arrange improvements" added in https://github.com/prusa3d/PrusaSlicer/releases/tag/version_2.6.1-rc1 have you tried PS 2.6.0? If so we may be able to port those improvements to Orca.

Noisyfox avatar Aug 24 '23 07:08 Noisyfox

Performance in 2.6 is the same. Screenshot from 2.6.0 (arrange options: distance 3.5 mm, 1 mm spacing to plate and rotation enabled): image

So, I guess, it does not matter whether you port 2.6 or 2.6.1 ;-) If I could make a wish, I'd like to be able to nest within objects => 2.6.1rc1 (I yet have to try - but I want to keep using OrcaSlicer ...).

foreachthing avatar Aug 24 '23 08:08 foreachthing

image Much better now. Still a lot of work to be done until it's usable but progress is made.

And with rotation on: image

Noisyfox avatar Sep 20 '23 08:09 Noisyfox

Not convinced, on my system 😆 image To be fair, this was with a custom bed shape.

And now, with a rectangle: Naaa... same difference. image

foreachthing avatar Sep 21 '23 07:09 foreachthing

Ah I didn't mean the production version. It's still under development and (mostly) working on my own dev branch.

Noisyfox avatar Sep 21 '23 07:09 Noisyfox

GitHub bot: this issue is stale because it has been open for 90 days with no activity.

github-actions[bot] avatar Dec 21 '23 00:12 github-actions[bot]

This has yet to be fixed: "Fill bed with copies" image

foreachthing avatar Dec 21 '23 20:12 foreachthing

Orca bot: this issue is stale because it has been open for 90 days with no activity.

github-actions[bot] avatar Mar 21 '24 00:03 github-actions[bot]

Still an issue with round build plates

kleinwareio avatar Mar 21 '24 15:03 kleinwareio

image

With rectangular plates too.

foreachthing avatar Mar 22 '24 10:03 foreachthing

Orca bot: this issue is stale because it has been open for 90 days with no activity.

github-actions[bot] avatar Jun 21 '24 00:06 github-actions[bot]

This looks niiiiice, in 2.1rc1!!! image

foreachthing avatar Jun 21 '24 11:06 foreachthing