Rolf Krahl comments

Results 40 comments of


                                            Rolf Krahl

Include physical object identifier such as inventory number

But our identifiers do not pertain to digital objects, they pertain to instruments, e.g. physical objects.

Include physical object identifier such as inventory number

Sorry, @huberrob, I really tried hard, but I don't get your point. Again: the instrument PID that we are discussing here does not identify any kind of digital object or...

Include physical object identifier such as inventory number

We discussed this in today's meeting: - we agreed that the PIDINST identifies the instrument, e.g. the physical object, not a digital representation. - assuming that the suggestion to amend...

Include physical object identifier such as inventory number

I'll reopen as requested by @huberrob. I will comment, maybe next week.

Include physical object identifier such as inventory number

I believe we have a consensus by now that the inventory number should be included as `AlternateIdentifier`. I suggest to close this one. Note that #24 is still open.

Include physical object identifier such as inventory number

@huberrob, I still believe that your distinction between the "physical object" and some "digital representation" of it (whatever that is supposed to mean) is artificial, it make things needlessly complicated...

Include physical object identifier such as inventory number

Regarding the information to locate the instrument, we discussed that in #17 and finally agreed not to add any additional information such as geo coordinates. For most instruments, the street...

Include physical object identifier such as inventory number

We already do have a place in the schema to include serial numbers and inventory numbers: `AlternateIdentifier`.

Include physical object identifier such as inventory number

In the preparation of submitting the schema as a RDA recommendation, we plan to get a decision on all pending open questions during the next monthly meeting on 4th August....

Include physical object identifier such as inventory number

Why would anybody want to create a PID for an instrument that does not exist? I would assume that any PIDINST is associated with a really existing physical instrument or...