osmcha-frontend icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
osmcha-frontend copied to clipboard

Edits seem to be grouped into changesets incorrectly

Open westnordost opened this issue 7 years ago • 1 comments

I'm submitting a bug report

Brief Description

Edits done on the same object are grouped into one changeset in the display, even if these changes have been done in different changesets.

What is the current behaviour?

Let's look at changeset 56188366: According to Osm Changeset Analyzer, the user added four tags on the Heidbusch road in that changeset: heidbusch-osmcha

However, looking at the history of the element in JOSM, one can see that the four changes were actually uploaded in three different changesets (i.e. look at the changeset number I framed with a green rectangle in the screenshot) heidbusch-josm

The changeset on OpenStreetMap also lists only version 10 of the way as being part of the 56188366 changeset: heidbusch-osm-history

What is the expected behaviour?

The expected behavior would be that OsmCha only shows the changes that really belong to the changeset that is currently shown

Other Information / context:

This bug was initially reported at https://github.com/westnordost/StreetComplete/issues/853 but it turned out it is only not displayed correctly.

westnordost avatar Feb 10 '18 14:02 westnordost

Also reported as #492

matkoniecz avatar Apr 01 '22 11:04 matkoniecz