freebsd 13.2 can not compile ,, it bugs

[jiadsii]

How are you using the lua-language-server?

Other

Which OS are you using?

Other

What is the issue affecting?

Other

Expected Behaviour

when i try to compile this in freebsd, it cannot coplete in once, and it reports error

Actual Behaviour

i think it never compile in freebsd 13.2

and i hope it can add a package for freebsd

Reproduction steps

i just do according to the document.

Additional Notes

No response

Log File

No response

[nospam2998]

Does it work better on FreeBSD 14.0-RELEASE? What are the exact commands run and the error message encountered?

[brianreichtcs]

I am also on FreeBSD 13.2. Here's my output from make.sh, if that helps.

output.txt

[nospam2998]

Thanks @brianreichtcs for logs and steps to reproduce. I get similar results with FreeBSD 14.0-RELEASE.

At least some of the errors seems to be from bee.lua, which is a submodule of lua-language-server. A brief look at the source code indicates that the BSD code merely points at the linux implementation. Without properly reading nor understand the details, I see mentions of inotify which natively is a linux specific API. An interesting quote from bee.lua#42 reads:

filewatch on freebsd is incomplete. filewatch depends on libinotify-kqueue, but unfortunately libinotify-kqueue doesn't work correctly.

Furthermore bee.lua#12 states that lua-language-server is unlikely to use filewatch, so the failing tests should be safe to ignore.

As far as I know, lua-language-server does not use filewatch, you can ignore this test.

Maybe it is possible add conditionals around irrelevant functionality and their tests? Either in bee.lua, lua-language-server or in the ports tree. I will unfortunately not be able to attempt that anytime soon though.

[brianreichtcs]

Fair enough :) I'm trying to work my team out of the FreeBSD business for exactly reasons like this. I thought given some more information maybe there'd be an existing solution, but didn't expect anyone to spend time on this to solve the issue for the 6 people it will impact. Thanks for looking it over, and thanks for all your efforts! Looking forward to using this package when we port over to Linux.

[vermaden]

These instructions seem to work on my FreeBSD 14.0 system - I needed to 'silence' two tests ...

# pkg install ninja

% git clone https://github.com/LuaLS/lua-language-server.git

% cd lua-language-server

% :> 3rd/bee.lua/test/test.lua

% :> test.lua

% ./make.sh

% ./bin/lua-language-server
Content-Length: 120

{"jsonrpc":"2.0","method":"$/status/report","params":{"text":"Lua","tooltip":"Cached files: 0/0\nMemory usage: 2M"}}

[brianreichtcs]

These instructions seem to work on my FreeBSD 14.0 system - I needed to 'silence' two tests ...

# pkg install ninja

% git clone https://github.com/LuaLS/lua-language-server.git

% cd lua-language-server

% :> 3rd/bee.lua/test/test.lua

% :> test.lua

% ./make.sh

% ./bin/lua-language-server
Content-Length: 120

{"jsonrpc":"2.0","method":"$/status/report","params":{"text":"Lua","tooltip":"Cached files: 0/0\nMemory usage: 2M"}}

Skipping the tests as you demonstrated makes the build succeed. Thanks so much!

[nospam2998]

For what it is worth, I tried and failed to package up a port. The attempt is available under this LuaLS branch.

Successful creation of a port would likely need to address a few issues. Among those:

• This software has no release tar balls, and due to using submodules for dependencies it is only buildable from within its git repository.
• All users launching this software needs to have write access to log files, which becomes under $PREFIX with my porting attempt.
• The compiled resulting binary fails to start with an error message about not finding bootstrap.lua, it also appears to look for main.lua directly in the root of $PREFIX/.

I'm giving up on creating this port for now. I still think it would be great to properly package this stuff though.