Pull-based behaviors?

[avieth]

trafficstars

The motivation: when doing DOM programming we sometimes wish to deal with the dimensions of elements. It seems natural to say that there is a Behavior Rect for an element's bounding client rectangle. But how to construct such a thing?? We would need an event to give the changes, but the DOM doesn't supply that, and polling it would probably grow prohibitively expensive. Why not compute it on-demand?

This patch defines fromPull :: IO a -> MomentIO (Behavior a) to produce pull-based behaviors. Ideally, the IO would run at most once per evaluation of the network. In this implementation, it's run at least 0 times. I have a feeling I'm doing something horribly wrong in newLatchIO.

What do you think? Good idea? Not so good? Consider this a feature request with code attached.

[HeinrichApfelmus]

Sorry for taking so long to have a look at this, and sorry that I can only triage this at the moment.

I think the idea is interesting and useful.

Note that the implementation of fromPull does not need a LatchWriter, the purpose of the latter is only to connect a Pulse and a Latch. In this case, everything can be implemented within the Latch record. The reason why your code does not work is probably that the _seenL value is not updated.

I think a correct implementation would simply be to apply cachedLatch to an IO action (lifted into the EvalL monad).

[mitchellwrosen]

Could this concept simply replace fromPoll? fromPull has the same type signature, and pulling only wen necessary seems preferable to polling on every input event.

[mitchellwrosen]

Note that the implementation of fromPull does not need a LatchWriter, the purpose of the latter is only to connect a Pulse and a Latch. In this case, everything can be implemented within the Latch record. The reason why your code does not work is probably that the _seenL value is not updated.

I think a correct implementation would simply be to apply cachedLatch to an IO action (lifted into the EvalL monad).

I believe if you implement this feature only with cachedLatch, the IO action will be performed as many times as the latch is evaluated. For example,

b <- fromPull (print 5)
e1 <- b <@ someEvent
e2 <- b <@ someEvent

reactimate (print 10 <$ e1)
reactimate (print 20 <$ e2)

Here, ideally the action print 5 would only be performed once. But because it's sampled by two different events, this would print

5
10
5
20

when someEvent fires.