free-programming-books icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
free-programming-books copied to clipboard

use pdf links for riptutorial

Open eshellman opened this issue 4 years ago • 19 comments
trafficstars

We have a few resources from riptutorial.com

We accepted a few with the credit " Compiled from StackOverflow Documentation"; it seemed similar to goalkicker which is a similar idea but IIRC reasonable for what it was.

I had a closer look at one of these, and I found it was mostly an unusable ad-infested content farm

Should we keep these or remove them?

eshellman avatar Oct 10 '21 22:10 eshellman

I’d say the PDFs should be acceptable as it follows the fundamental principles and guidelines of the usual content that’s submitted in this repository (at least from first glance with the given examples). Additionally, I’d recommend making further contributing guideline changes on websites that are solely/mainly designed for ad-farming. It really doesn’t fit in with the repository’s professionalism, but drawing the line to what can be considered as “ad-farming” can be somewhat subjective. My personal recommendation would be to avoid adding HTML tutorials of the website.

kernelwernel avatar Oct 10 '21 22:10 kernelwernel

My two pennies...

  • HTML :-1:
  • PDF :+1:

Goalkicker

  • Website: Several G.Ads related with books buying.
  • Pdfs: has minimum references to website

Riptutorial

  • Searching for advertisers in a website section with 6 banner/affiliate types. USA & India are the hot target.
  • No ads are shown to me 🤔 (maybe due to decline cookies)
  • PDFs. Several links mentioning read this topic on the website (most of that html pages with few content... "ad-farming" ???)
  • PDF accepts a variety of languages: topic-locale.pdf. E.g.:
    • English: https://riptutorial.com/Download/angular-2.pdf
    • Spanish: https://riptutorial.com/Download/angular-2-es.pdf
  • if accepted... authoring should be Free unaffiliated eBook created from StackOverflow contributors as seen in the front book cover ??
  • There are topics not covered by Goalkicker, although with few chapters each one.

Let's compare some resources about a big topic, (e.g. java) and decide.

Of course better be focussed in these free resources (mostly books) without any ads in sources

I will take care about it.

davorpa avatar Oct 11 '21 00:10 davorpa

No ads showed for me either, not sure why. I assumed it was some configuration I did on my browser that I forgot about or something.

kernelwernel avatar Oct 11 '21 00:10 kernelwernel

None of the pdfs I tried to download from one book downloaded. Not sure what was going on there.

eshellman avatar Oct 11 '21 12:10 eshellman

sample: image

eshellman avatar Oct 16 '21 17:10 eshellman

also insterstial ads every few clicks.

eshellman avatar Oct 16 '21 17:10 eshellman

Ah, I didn't think it would be that bad. I'd further push for changes to remove riptutorials.

kernelwernel avatar Oct 16 '21 17:10 kernelwernel

sample: image

It's just I mention here https://github.com/EbookFoundation/free-programming-books/issues/6153#issuecomment-939582590

  • PDFs. Several links mentioning read this topic on the website (most of that html pages with few content... "ad-farming" ???)

davorpa avatar Oct 16 '21 23:10 davorpa

What if you replaced the link to the page with the direct link to the pdf instead? It would solve the problem of ads.

LuigiImVector avatar Oct 17 '21 09:10 LuigiImVector

What if you replaced the link to the page with the direct link to the pdf instead? It would solve the problem of ads.

The PDF has several links to these pages https://github.com/EbookFoundation/free-programming-books/issues/6153#issuecomment-939582590. Download one :wink:

davorpa avatar Oct 17 '21 23:10 davorpa

The PDF has several links to these pages #6153 (comment). Download one 😉

I know but the books are very interesting and it's a shame not to include them. Maybe you could put a notice next to the link saying that there are numerous advertisements on the page....

LuigiImVector avatar Oct 18 '21 13:10 LuigiImVector

could someone post a "good" pdf link so we can be talking about the same thing?

eshellman avatar Oct 19 '21 02:10 eshellman

could someone post a "good" pdf link so we can be talking about the same thing?

C++ book pdf: https://riptutorial.com/Download/cplusplus.pdf

Saurabh-Daware avatar Oct 24 '21 07:10 Saurabh-Daware

Thanks @Saurabh-Daware Yes, the pdfs are fine. let's make sure riptutorial links are to the pdf.

eshellman avatar Oct 24 '21 14:10 eshellman

Thanks @Saurabh-Daware Yes, the pdfs are fine. let's make sure riptutorial links are to the pdf.

And authoring text?

  1. The same used in Goalkicker: Compiled from StackOverflow Documentation
  2. As seen in front cover of PDFs: Free unaffiliated eBook created from StackOverflow contributors
  3. other...

davorpa avatar Oct 24 '21 16:10 davorpa

same as goalkicker

eshellman avatar Oct 25 '21 17:10 eshellman

  • Its my first time to hear about ad-farming.
  • Gonna rectify link and direct it to pdf

BulegaHassan avatar Mar 03 '22 15:03 BulegaHassan

I'd like to contribute a system design handbook. Please grant me permission to contribute and I'm committed to following all guidelines and standards. Thank you for your consideration.

SAGARGAUD01 avatar Oct 11 '23 09:10 SAGARGAUD01

I am not admin to grant permissions but hope that you do a research about who gives such permissions

On Wed, Oct 11, 2023 at 12:10 PM sagar gaud @.***> wrote:

I'd like to contribute a system design handbook. Please grant me permission to contribute and I'm committed to following all guidelines and standards. Thank you for your consideration.

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/EbookFoundation/free-programming-books/issues/6153#issuecomment-1757218429, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AVZHTEUITXCPW25X6WWMEZ3X6ZPARANCNFSM5FW5VSYA . You are receiving this because you commented.Message ID: @.***>

BulegaHassan avatar Oct 11 '23 11:10 BulegaHassan