context-mapper-dsl icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
context-mapper-dsl copied to clipboard

Allow for linking concrete code

Open koppor opened this issue 4 years ago • 1 comments

For me, documentation should offer links to the code. For example, the "implementation" of an Entity should be linkable.

GitHub allows for copying permalinks. They could be used: https://github.com/JabRef/jabref/blob/f3283637b3163e9a736df8354d28c5fc3297a824/src/main/java/org/jabref/model/entry/BibEntry.java#L56

With that, an interested reader could directly jump to the code.

  • Advanced (follow-up) feature: Allow for jumping to the code in the favorite IDE.
  • Advanced (follow-up) feature: Alarm the user if the code changes and the domain model should be changed. https://swimm.io/ demonstrates how this could work.

koppor avatar Oct 19 '21 20:10 koppor

Hi @koppor

Thanks for your input!

With "documentation" you mean a CML model in this context, right? You would like to be able to jump from the CML editor, for example by clicking on a modeled entity, to the implementation of the corresponding entity? Interesting request, but also very tricky to implement. I wonder whether a solution just for GitHub would help many users, as many probably don't work in an open-source (GitHub) context. Jumping to the corresponding implementation directly in the IDE would probably be even better then leaving the IDE and go to the browser.

Advanced (follow-up) feature: Alarm the user if the code changes and the domain model should be changed.

This actually already works with our ArchUnit extension: Validating the Implementation against the Model I use it in my projects so that if the code changes the build will error unless I adjust the domain model accordingly. But of course, you only realize it after you have run the build or get notified by your CI that the build is broken. A warning directly in the IDE would be nicer; I agree :)

stefan-ka avatar Oct 21 '21 06:10 stefan-ka