openexr icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
openexr copied to clipboard

Feature request: make deeptile files with exrmaketiled

Open fnordware opened this issue 12 years ago • 4 comments

exrmaketiled does not work with deep data right now. Let's fix that.

fnordware avatar Aug 09 '13 20:08 fnordware

Looking into the OpenEXR issue backlog. Is this an issue, or safe to close?

cary-ilm avatar Jun 28 '19 23:06 cary-ilm

Well, it's a feature request. The exrmaketiled utility can turn a scanline EXR into a tiled EXR. Might be nice if it could do the same for deep.

fnordware avatar Jun 28 '19 23:06 fnordware

Do you have a use case? Making a one level tiled deep image would be trivial, but the OpenEXR library doesn't support filtering of deep pixels to produce mipmap/ripmap images. Robust deep filtering is a hard problem.

Unless there's a compelling demand for converting scanline deep images to one level tiled deep images, it may be better not to support deep scanline images at all in exrmaketiled until it has feature parity with regular scanline image inputs.

peterhillman avatar Jun 30 '19 20:06 peterhillman

Well, that's a good point.

I guess if someone wants it badly enough they can implement it themselves.

fnordware avatar Jul 01 '19 16:07 fnordware