vexflow icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
vexflow copied to clipboard

Three_Voice_Rests Three_Voices____2_Complex Test - Visual Error

Open rvilarl opened this issue 3 years ago • 4 comments

Beam and notehead overlapping.

Three_Voice_Rests Three_Voices____2_Complex Bravura

rvilarl avatar Jan 30 '22 08:01 rvilarl

This may be a regression. (It's also a very contrived example -- I don't think this is how this musical snippet would be written out anyway.)

0xfe avatar Jan 30 '22 11:01 0xfe

This may be a regression. (It's also a very contrived example -- I don't think this is how this musical snippet would be written out anyway.)

Oh -- I was just playing today a number of piano pieces that had passages like this, so it's not that uncommon. But I don't think that the professional desktop notation software solved this (or if so not till recently) so I don't think it's worth holding up getting it in. A test that currently fails in a complex case is fine to keep, and then we can keep it for something to fix later.

mscuthbert avatar Jan 31 '22 05:01 mscuthbert

Already present in 3.0.9

image

rvilarl avatar Jan 31 '22 06:01 rvilarl

(I'd skip the bug label and call it "enhancement" or future work or something; it's different from other "bugs" in that it's an unsolved problem in algorithmic music layout.)

mscuthbert avatar Mar 02 '22 23:03 mscuthbert